Presti's Bakery - Bakery and Cake Shop in Cleveland - 12101 Mayfield Rd, USA

Good Italian style desserts offering cookies, cannolis, gelato and other small cakes. Also offers small bites that you can microwave and eat in their dining area. You pull a ticket and they call on a first come, first serve basis. Interestingly (and perhaps a little slight of hand), they don’t post any prices for their items. You order and the price is a surprise! Of note, they charge $22 per pound of cookies.

The bathroom is gross, like scared to know the last time it was cleaned. The store itself is gross, and floor corners are black filled with crumbs. Regardless of how wonderful the cream puff is, it makes me worry about how clean the kitchen is compared. Definitely needs a deep cleaning and some attention to the details.

We visited Presti's Bakery after spending the morning at the Cleveland Museum of Art (which is a must see) and before heading over to the Cleveland Museum of Natural History, and it was the perfect way to cap off an already perfect morning. Cream puff + apple turnover + chocolate dipped coconut macaroon + tall latte = a perfect morning!

Came here for my first time tonight after eating next door. Oh man what a selection! Not just cookies either. All types of cheese cakes and pastries. As well as a coffee bar that serves lattes. I had a chia latte as well as a cherry turnover and some Italian cheesecake. Everything wad amazing!

Quite possibly the first perfectly cooked cheesecake I've ever consumed. Grab a number, get some good eats. Slightly pretentious staff, but worth it. I'm also a dumb country boy, so what do I know? Maybe they were just tired. This is a worthwhile stop in Cleveland. Worth going out of your way a bit. I do like baked goods, and these guys have the 100 year history of doing it right, it seems.

Presti's bakery exceeded my expectations! The vanilla cappuccino was delicious and my family absolutely loved all of the baked goods! The staff was extremely kind and helped me decide on which baked goods to get. I highly recommend stopping in at Presti's bakery if you get the opportunity.

Great Italian bakery and eatery with many delicious options to choose from, right in the heart of little Italy 🇮🇹. Staffing could be a bit better with more front counter employees to match the influx of patrons during weekends.

3.7 stars. Clean bakery with many sweets to choose from. Lack of pricing made it hard to tell what each item cost. Ordered two drip coffees ($4 each), lemon square ($4), chocolate canoli ($4.50), and a cream puff ($6.50). Cream puff pricing was surprising given that you'd expect a canoli to cost more. Lemon square was more a cake with a glaze on it. Would definitely get the canoli and cream puff agin but not the lemon square. Employees were a bit curt and could've been a tad friendlier.