Yoder's Restaurant & Amish Village - Restaurant in Sarasota - 3434 Bahia Vista St, USA

Love Yoders! It is definitely a unique experience. The food is high-quality and definitely homemade. Local Amish eat here so when locals eat somewhere, you always know it’s good! They have some great gift shops and farmers markets in the area. Fun trip to Sarasota!

A friendly place to get a meal. Our server was attentive and professional. Stopped in for breakfast and although not perfect was very good. I ordered the mushroom bacon and cheese omelet with grits and biscuit. Not a fan of sliced cheese on top of omelet. I'd rather have graded cheese inside to mix with the other ingredients. The grits were excellent but swimming in butter. The biscuit was moist goodness. Add a little homemade apple butter for extra deliciousness. Another at table got the bacon, egg, and cheese breakfast sandwich. He thoroughly enjoyed it. The hash Browns were tasty to. Not a perfect meal but a nice experience. Would definitely return.

We were sat right away. The restroom is in the server alleyway. Strange and small. The chicken salad was delicious. The country fried steak was great. The pie was amazingly delicious. The crust is crispy and the portion of pie is shareable. Our server did a wonderful job.

This is my favorite type of breakfast dinner! Low-key with excellent food! The service is great 👍 quick and friendly always with a smile. The coffee is everything you want in dinner coffee, light roast in a good old fashioned mug. I had the eggs benedict. It was sublime 😋 that dish is a subtle dance between light and airy, and rich. They nailed it.

Food was great. We ate breakfast and had the Country Benedict which was very good, but the star of the show was one of their daily special muffins. The blueberry cream cheese muffin was superb. The service was fantastic and very interesting decor.

Est. 1975 Layout/atmosphere *Homey; one room with wooden tables & booths; glass display case with pie slices in the center; photos of the Amish citizens on the walls; pies sold at counter by entrance; parking lot Service *Quick but friendly Food/drink *Country Breakfast (chicken fried steak with pepper gravy, two eggs/over easy, home fries & a biscuit) - Good; steak/gravy not too heavy; the homemade apple butter on the biscuit was sweet & delicious *Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie - OK; liked the crust but bit messy/too much whipped cream

Great home cooked meals and Midwestern comfort food! Cakes and pies are delicious as well! You have to try the fried chicken that's for sure!

Great service, amazing food large portions. Everyone is super friendly and helpful. I drove a 100 miles to check the place out . Soooo goood , I will definitely be going back ..:)