Wiseguy Pizza Pie - Pizza restaurant in Hailey - 411 N Main St, USA

Stopped in on a busy Saturday night and still had a great time! All food came out quick considering how busy it was and everything was really good! Ordered the Fat Guy, buffalo wings and cheese bread! Pizza & Cheese Bread 8/10 buffalo wings…. 10/10!!!

The meat pizza was fantastic, coupled with ham and pineapple, amazing. The garlic knots were yummy, and the hamburger and fries were tasty and filling. The staff was wonderful, and many of the patrons are locals, which means this must be good.

Pretty terrible experience overall. Food: we ordered the fun guy and the margarita as well as a salad. Got off to a rough start when They were out of lettuce but we told them we were ok with substitutions and they made the base with spinach (which ended up being good). The pizzas were overpriced and not good. The margharita pizza was basically tomato sauce with a few specks of mozzarella and they "forgot" to put basil on it. For a pizza with only 3 ingredients, it's not great if they don't remember one. Crust was overcooked and the sauce was overwhelming. We tried the fun guy which sounded great but came out as a soggy mess of mushrooms. The dough was so wet the pizza was falling apart immediately which is never a good sign. Taste was pretty terrible. Service: really bad unfortunately. For a place where you go up to the counter to order, we didn't have high expectations anyways but they didn't even meet those. The woman at the counter was very nice but then everything went downhill from there. They kept forgetting to bring us bowls and plates (we were only a group for 4 so I didn't anticipate that this would be a challenge). We went up twice to ask for more bowls and plates when the pizza came up. When the second pizza came out, the server was very frazzled that we were going to have two pizzas on the table and told us he didn't know what to do since there was no room. This actually made us laugh until we realized he was definitely not joking. They had no pizza stackers so we moved some things around and were able to fit everything no problem, without any assistance from the server who promptly just walked away. Overall a really bizarre and pretty bad experience. Definitely not worth going to if you can go to any other place to eat.

The food is horrible! Cheeseburger was done to the point of inedible. The meatball hoagie had scant sauce. Burned bun. Also inedible. The salad was OK! Also was very very cold inside. Won't go back.

Ordered a pepperoni pizza to go. Out of 100. 97 % grease 1 % dough maybe 1% cheese 1% Pepperoni. The dough was thinner than a dollar bill. We both got sick in less than 30 minutes. NEVER AGAIN. I paid by card and it added over 7.00 tip. I was not putting the tip on my card. I gave cash tip. Wow.

I love this place, this is my go to for pizza. The slices are so thin, you can eat 3 slices guilt free! (I sure did). Even just ordering cheese, it bursts with flavor I love the tomato sauce they use. The service is always nice, I’ve never had a problem going to either location. It’s worth trying at least once, because once you do you’ll be hooked.

I tried to eat dinner in Hailey, ID after 8pm and there isn't much open, so I tried Wise Guys. It was good. There is no table service, so you order at the reception area, pay, and then go sit and wait. The wait time was not long. The food was pretty good. I like thin crust pizza a lot, so I was looking forward to it. It wasn't bad, but the sauce is a little bland without much flavor. I thought the price was extremely high, $19 for a 14" pizza. Yikes! I ordered garlic knits as well, and they were very good. The atmosphere was not great for me, but I'm an older guy, so take that critique with a grain of salt. The music was too loud for a conversation, and heavy metal is not my thing. Overall, this place has good food, but be ready to pay dearly.

Absolutely the best Garlic Knots I've ever had, and the pizza was amazing!