Toasted - Windermere - Sandwich shop in Windermere - 6506 Old Brick Rd, USA

WOW!!! If you like grilled cheese, you will LOVE Toasted! It would be a sin to overlook this restaurant if you are in the area! We tried 3 different sandwiches and the Truffle Fries, and all of them were excellent! The Truffle Melt was wonderful, and I highly recommend the Truffle Honey Mustard with it and the fries! 😍 The Buffalo Chicken had a slight kick but great flavor! The Braised Brisket was very good, and you MUST try the Sriracha BBQ sauce!!! 🥰❤️🔥 Mikailah 🙂 was super helpful and gave us some great suggestions! I definitely plan on coming back here! Don't miss a great opportunity!

We had the “As Gouda As It Gets” and “Barbacoa Melt”. Both were really good. Great taste and size! We also got a “Mac & Cheese toasted” and fries. The Mac & cheese was very good but really small portion for the price. The fries were crispy and enough for 2 to share so a good size portion. One thing I would change or add if I can would to be to have a choice of bread but over all it was good and I would recommend and definitely go back again

I love Toasted, but my family usually bemoans going as they don't enjoy it nearly as much as I do. I love the tomato soup, whereas they don't like it. We all agree the fries are good. We also differ on entrees. Great atmosphere, very cool theming. Service is usually sub-par, though.

I had the Southern Comfort burger and it was pretty tasty, but a bit less than I expected it to be. The mac and cheese sort of blended in with the bun, and while the barbecue sauce was tasty, it was almost too subtle -- I would have liked it to be a bit more aggressive. That said, the burger was cooked nicely, pinkish inside and with just the right char on the outside. Fries are extra, so the meal can get a tad pricey, but it was still good enough that if be happy to go back.

Came in for a pressed sandwich, clean establishment. Ordered the truffle fries the fig and goat sandwich and the barbacoa melt. Sandwiches were a bit over pressed but flavors were ok. I couldn’t get over how unprofessional a staff member was dressed serving food at the front end and within the shop to families. Being a family establishment that caters to all there should be a dress code of conduct and a higher regard and respect to the customers. I will not be coming back or recommending this sandwich shop to anyone. Where was management ? How is this ok ? Just awful.

I LOOOOVVVVE me a good ooey gooey grilled cheese so when a grilled cheese spot pops up you know I'm there. I've been eyeing up Toasted for a hot minute and after a long work day yesterday we decided to pop in and see what it was all about. Before I get into the food I need to take a moment to point out that they have CHEESE GRATERS as pendant lights. As an interior designer, this may be my absolute FAVORITE part of the entire restaurant. It made my night.....grate (sorry I had to). They also have a great periodic table of cheese and a neon "get toasted" sign on the wall that are great for instagraming some food selfies! 📸 Now, onto the melty stuff. We shared two sandwiches, one was the Fig & Goat and the other was the Mac Attack. The Fig & Goat was subtle and delicate and the bread was either stale or overtoasted because it was tough to bite into. Which was a little disappointing since the Goat cheese was so melty and smooth, I wish the bread could have added a nice light crispy factor. The Mac Attack was pretty dang amazing. All the flavors were there, it was a little light on the bacon and there was barely any arugula but it didn't ruin the experience. My only complaint would be the side of the sandwiches. I expected to have some loaded up grilled goodness that was dripping with epic cheese pulls butttttt it was lacking. The sandwiches are on the thin side and they definitely weren't cheesy enough for some cheese pull footage. On the flip side, the price point is lower than some other competitors in the area that offer unique grilled cheeses so, keep that in mind. Lower price, less fillings. It's a give and take. The taste of everything was still great and while idk if I'd choose to go there again for grilled cheeses I'd certainly try out their burgers!

Had an amazing experience at Toasted. Delicious vegan menu with options to upgrade to an Impossible Patty. The vegan cheese truffle fries are what dreams are made of. We ordered the Sweet Heat Impossible burger as well as the Vegan Bahn Mi Burger. Staff was friendly and place was really clean. Can't wait to come back, thanks for having vegan options!

Great little burger shop and you can sit outside. They have vegan options (impossible burger). Also they have normal people food which is extra tasty.