The Upper Crust - Restaurant in Gettysburg - 19 York St, USA

The Upper Crust is a great spot for lunch or dinner. My son and I have been coming to Gettysburg for years and tried this place for the first time and it was a great experience. The waitress was friendly and helpful. The restaurant is very clean and has an amazing atmosphere. The wood fired ovens are really cool to see. They have basketball, pool and other activities you can do inside the restaurant. The pizza is probably the best pizza I've ever had and I been to a ton of pizza places. I high recommend this restaurant. In the spring and summer they open the front up so you can enjoy the outside environment while you're still eating inside the restaurant. They also offer outdoor seating.

A gem and a find! We love this place and go there for lunch every time we are in Gettysburg. The wood burned pizza is great. Perfect crust- generous toppings. Their pesto roasted cauliflower? Hummus? Authentic and homemade. Fantastic! Lots of good salads, brisket… the food is excellent. Another perk?!?! The free games. We played basketball, pool, air hockey… such a fun place.

I ate at the upper crust for the first time, I can say it's my new favorite eating spot in Gettysburg. They have the three beehive woodstoves it's a very open atmosphere not to compact or small feeling. I had the beef brisket which was delicious. The inside smells slightly of wood smoke which is so nice and appealing. I love this place.

The food and atmosphere were amazing! The games were all free and a perfect setting if you have kiddos. The server was rude but maybe she was just having a busy night. We will try it out again.

First time here and it was excellent. This should be 5-stars… Their drink menu is excellent - the smoked orange old fashioned was great and they have a good beer list. Food: the calamari were also great - seasoned and cooked well. The portion size was small for the price. The brisket pizza was also quite good, but two things, 1. There wasn’t much brisket and 2. What was on the pizza should be added a closer to the end of cook time. Lastly, this place needs a Thai chicken pizza…like the old Gettysburg Brewing company had that used to be next door.

Excellent selection of craft beers, an extensive whiskey selection, and wood fired pizzas that were really good. Free games in the back were a cool addition as well grabbed a table to split between a few people who were in town for an event we hosted at a local brewery. Staff were all personably and friendly, gave their recommendations for pizza that did not disappoint. Hoping to be able to get back and really see what all they have to offer soon.

Went to lunch with a handful of coworkers. Very neat atmosphere! Lots of space and people chatting away while at the tables, bar, or playing games in the back. We were seated right away and our waitress was extremely nice and sweet. She answered all our questions and helped us decide things we may want to order. I ordered the Fish Fry Sandwich, which was delicious! And the fries had just the right amount of Old Bay seasoning. For my drinks I had the amazing Cranberry Orange Mimosa (two of them) and water. My coworker ordered pizza and each of them said it was very good. We were too full to order desert but I'm sure they were good as well. We plan to return in the future.

My family loves this place. Amazing food options. The pizza's fantastic. You can also order barbecue from the place next door. This place has a bar for the adults, craft beer. And a game area for kids to play pool tables, shuffleboard and basketball hoops. We love watching the pizzas being cooked in the wood fired ovens. We also love the open garage doors to the front Love the establishment. The brisket pizza with ricotta is one of our favorites!! We also love the hush puppies and the mac and cheese bites. You can't go wrong with any other pizzas here our kids love the pepperoni obviously. The pizzas are personal size and they run about $18 to $20.