The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Co. - Bagel shop in Lake Mary - 3801 W Lake Mary Blvd #139, USA

Very good bagels. I had egg and nova on a poppy bagel with veggie cheese. My brother has egg cheese and pastrami on an everything bagel. He says the pastrami was chewy. Bagel shops up North always have that mom and pop feel. This place not so much felt too commercialized. But overall good bagels.

The most delicious Bagels in Lake Mary!!! I pass a couple bagel shops to come here for my breakfast Bagel Sandwiches. It is so cool to see the display where you walk in showing the Brooklyn water used in making their Bagels. You have to check this place out for your Brooklyn Breakfast!!!

The bagels we got were very good, Jersey Boy, Brooklyn and two plain bagels with cream cheese. The cubsta iced coffee is cool with the coffee ice cubes. The hash browns were awful. They had no flavor what so ever and limp like a noodle. They had no substance to them at all. It is a little pricey for bagels. $50 for 4 bagels and drinks. The girl who took our order was not friendly at all. It was our first time here, you’d think she would recommend something or be overly friendly but nothing. She didn’t smile, it was like she was pissed to be at work. No one had name tags on, but she had huge hoop earrings on. Another lovely worker did come and check on us and ask us how we liked everything. She was super nice and thanked us for coming in. First impressions can be deceiving so I’ll give this place another chance and maybe come for lunch. A smile can go a long way so have your cashiers be a little more pleasant.

This empty thing was 8.00. Ordered a ham and pepper jack cheese with garlic and jalapenos. Tons O' bagel....where is my ham!!!! 1/2 lb my Donkey. Not getting my money any more.

Update: This place is filthy! There are no clean tables, and food and garbage is all over the floor. I hope the kitchen is clean. 🤢 Their food is great (best bagels ever) and their staff is always nice, helpful and fast. Their Cubista coffee is my favorite--the coffee ice cubes prevent your iced coffee from becoming watered down.

The reason for the low rating is that you cannot check out without leaving a tip. I went in to buy a dozen bagels and pay with a credit card. The device would not let me complete the order without leaving a tip. It had several levels of tips to select or a make your own tip. I went to make your own tip and it would not accept no tip. I finally put in a tip and completed the order. I think merchants are going overboard. I don't believe a tip is in order when someone puts a dozen bagels in a bag. we don't tip at the bakery, seafood, or meat department in a grocery store. It's upsetting enough that I may not return to this merchant.

I’m from NJ and have lived in FL for 15 years. This is the first and only bagel shop I’ve been to in the state with bagels that taste like a bagel should. So happy I found this place. 10/10 recommend.

This was my first time here. Being originally from Jersey, I know bagels. I had everything bagel which was absolutely perfect. I did order the jersey boy which was supposed to be Taylor, ham, egg and cheese. Being from New Jersey, I knew right away, that they used generic ham for their sandwich. Taylor him egg and cheese is specific to the New Jersey area and it requires a special ham in a white cloth wrapper. Any other ham is considered ham, egg and cheese on a bagel. Was I disappointed? Actually, I was. I really thought that a place from up north would know what a real Taylor him, egg and cheese was. Additionally, The eggs appeared to be microwaved. However, I will be back for some amazing bagels and to try some other dishes!! The bagels are amazing and after all that's what this place is!