The Original Anthony's Pizza - Pizza restaurant in DeBary - 155 S Charles Richard Beall Blvd, USA

New York style pizza. New York style service (big, loud, and fun). Fun atmosphere. Hole in the wall joint. Some of the very best pizza I’ve had. Not from around here, so it’ll be a while till I’m back. But I will be.

Awesome pizza, stopped by for lunch today, 1st visit. Got the pizza & salad lunch combo absolutely delicious. Place had the old timely Ny Italian pizza place feel. The crust was definitely 🔥 will definitely go again.

I’ve been here twice and the woman who worked there was amazing. My food came quick and the pizza was good. Today, for my third time, my brother and I went there on break. We have an hour break and work 5 minutes away. We decided to sit and eat there. We ordered 3 cheese slices and a pepperoni slice and two sprites. We got there at 12:15 and waited until 12:50 to cancel our order because we had to be back at work for a meeting at 1p.m. When we told her we need to cancel the order to get back to work and that we would just pay for the sprite, her demeanor was negative and she charged us $6 for two fountain sprites that we had a sip of. This lady that I am talking about isn’t the one I mentioned before. Bad business. You’ve lost business and now our coworkers will not be back there either. If you’re on lunch break, DONT GO THERE! At least when there are the younger group working there. We didn’t even get an apology in which perhaps would have deterred me from writing this review. DO BETTER YOUNG LADY WITH YOUR EMPATHY AND ATTITUDE! 4 slices does not take over 30 minutes to make. Let me add that they had two people at one booth and two people at another table so it wasn’t crowded at all. If she would have told us the wait would be over 30 minutes, we would have left and to charge us 6 bucks for two fountain drinks when they should’ve been on the house for their delay. Very disappointing.

I keep trying to support a local business but it seems that with every recent order it gets worse. The positive is that it at least tastes okay. But we ordered a double pepperoni pizza and they skipped out on half of the pepperoni (not the first time they shorted the toppings), the pizza was so uneven that I couldn't even pick up my slice because it was so thin. So after paying with a tip and fees a total of $48 I find myself adding my own pepperoni and putting the pizza back in the oven to cook the bottom more. Do better!

On today July 29th 2023 At 6:30 PM EST whoever cooked this pie… you are an American treasure.. born and bred for the single purpose of sliding a combination of raw dough, sauce, cheese and pepperoni while guiding it to crisp to perfection. You laughed at mediocrity and refused to give me some sloppy undercooked cheesy mess, no! You delivered a masterpiece that took knowledge only a true pizza connoisseur could deliver. For that I raise my glass to you and humbly award you 5 stars.

Absolutely love this place. We tried it about a year ago and have now become regulars. Their pizzas and canzones are our favorite. The staff is extremely friendly as well. Highly recommend.

My wife and I really enjoyed our experience at Anthony's Pizza. She enjoyed a pizza and I with a huge (small) Calzone. The entire staff made it a pleasurable evening. We will definitely be coming back. Thank you all ...

I'm from Brooklyn, NY. As you all know, we have some of the best pizzerias. This place comes close to home. The pizza is on the money ny style, the wings where finger licking is good . Garlic knots were great, and meatballs were close to momma kitchen. I would go here with any of my NY friends and family come in for a visit for sure. The service is top knotch she keeps on top of your table very good at her job. Highly recommend this place.