The Old Fashioned - Restaurant in Madison - 23 N Pinckney St #1, USA

It was a busy Saturday night but drinks and food came out quickly. The meat and fish Susan was incredible! I tried out the Applejack old fashioned and it was only okay, not my cup of tea, but they have a full bar and the other drinks excellent. Ordered the chili and prime rib.. Waaay too much food but oh so good! Highly recommend the Wisconsin Cheese Soup. 10/10

On a Saturday there was an estimated 1 hour wait but it took 1.5 hours. The food was pretty good, but it's over hyped I would say. The burger did taste really good also I would suggest it! But the fries could for sure use an upgrade compared to others in the area. Worth a check out!

I got the chicken biscuits & gravy. A new and better take on a chicken pot pie. Absolutely delicious, highly recommend. Fried curds were fantastic. Friendly staff. It does get crowded quickly, and is a bit too loud. Make reservations if you can

The Old Fashioned is a very very popular place, and can take a party quite a while to find seats on a busy night. Luckily, the bar seating is a free for all and you can find accommodations much quicker there. The cheese curds are indeed cheesy, and the double brat sandwich had tasty bratwursts, though quickly turned into a fork and knife situation when the roll gave up the struggle holding the sausages in. The muddled old fashions and a cherry cordial were both made well.

The Old Fashioned Tavern & Restaurant in Madison, Wisconsin is a great place to go for delicious food and a relaxed atmosphere. I've been there several times, and I'm always impressed by the quality of the food and the friendly service. The menu features a variety of classic American dishes, as well as some more unique options. I highly recommend the fish fry on Fridays, which is made with fresh, local fish and served with all the fixings. The burgers are also excellent, and the prime rib on Saturdays is a must-try. In addition to the great food, The Old Fashioned also has a great atmosphere. The restaurant is decorated in a classic tavern style, with a warm and inviting feel. The staff is always friendly and attentive, and they go out of their way to make sure that you have a good time. Whether you're looking for a casual place to grab a bite to eat or a place to celebrate a special occasion, The Old Fashioned is a great option. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a great dining experience in Madison, Wisconsin. Here are some specific things I love about The Old Fashioned: The food is always delicious and made with fresh ingredients. The staff is friendly and attentive. The atmosphere is warm and inviting. The restaurant is located in a convenient location in downtown Madison. The prices are reasonable. Overall, I highly recommend The Old Fashioned Tavern & Restaurant to anyone looking for a great dining experience in Madison, Wisconsin.

Excellent cheese curds and Wisconsin old fashioned. Shared the chicken and biscuits and it was the perfect portion for each of us. Tasted just like a homemade chicken pot pie. Yum! Totally worth the 20 minute detour off the freeway!

Loud patrons ruin the experience for people who are out with friends for a meal and a beverage. There is no way to fix that problem however. The server was attentive and the pickled beet salad is something I'll replicate at home! My friends loved the fried fish dishes they ordered. Delicious! When in Wisconsin try the beer cheese soup! 😁

Ordered their famous old fashioned drink and their famous cheese curds, both were delicious! Also had a brats sandwich, very good as well. Highly recommend!