Ted's Montana Grill - American restaurant in Indianapolis - 5910 W 86th St Suite 134, USA

Was very surprised to find it not busy for a Sunday evening. Was greeted as we entered the door, and seated promptly. Staff were wonderful, made suggestions, and answered all questions about menu. Ordered the Bison NY Strip, and it was great.

Delicious! I ate here a long time ago when they first opened with my father. It’s not fine dining, but the atmosphere feels like that. Wait staff was friendly and on it. Burger was excellent! Onion rings were excellent, the cook needs to be shake the basket so they don’t stick, some under cooked. Only complaint. Worth a try if your haven’t been….

Pretty good food. Definitely a unique experience and a good way to be exposed to bison burgers and bison in general. The first time I went here was on my birthday a couple years ago. I had the bison bacon cheeseburger and it was really delicious. Definitely have the burgers medium well for the best flavor and texture. The meat is very lean so well done will change the taste and texture. This time I went with more people and we all got different things we hadn't had before. I got a table early and a waiter came over to take my drink order and offered to take an order for an appetizer while I waited. He was very polite and made sure my drink or my son's was ever empty. Very attentive waiter and friendly. He offered the items of the day and some of us tried them. The devour Indy event was still active so that was an option as well. Absolutely an idea to consider and it is a great way to try the food at a good cost. The food was good and came out very quickly. When we ordered dessert we also ordered a to go order and they came out at the same time. Very fast service. Pleasant atmosphere and nice clean restaurant. I will go back again and try some new menu items. Good for families and groups to enjoy a meal. Update August 2, 2023 Ordered a takeout order. Arrived and waited to get some sides. Kept waiting. A server asked if I had everything and I said I needed to sides of ranch. She walked off and never returned. After waiting a while and having other employees just stare at me and do nothing. I left. Such a disappointing. With only two tables with people why is service so poor?

#AccordingToArmon Ted’s Montana Grill is a 5 star restaurant when it comes to their burgers!!! My wife & I ordered The George’s Cadillac Cheeseburger which is comparable to a basic cheeseburger; just with Bison meat & The Canyon Creek burger included a hard cooked egg & jalapeño! All burgers come with a side of Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle and Onion! We also ordered French fries & Onion rings and to be honest, the onion rings were okay, but the French fries were pretty tasty! Overall, for 2 meals, we pay a little over $35, and our waitress Melissa was very friendly, timely, and right on time when it came to her customer service! We will definitely be back!

Had the Bison Steak for the first time, the taste was delicious! It was cooked perfect to my specifications and the parmesan broccoli phenomenal!

We enjoyed our lunch - everything was top notch. From the fresh cut chips with awesome dipping sour cream! Everything was A+ to the bison burgers. The mojito bartender does needs another try because that was the lowest part of the meal....but equally expensive. $50 is not a cheap meal for 2, however with 1 alcoholic drink and 2 burger meals......hummm ouch that lunch did hurt a bit but its really BISON!!! Still this is a great place to get solid quality food. I will be back and this place even though I believe is costly is worth that cost! Will recommend

Service was great. The decor is nice, somewhat of a high end look but still inviting. The pickles they serve when you sit down are a little too salty for my taste. Nice and crispy though. The chopped salad was fantastic, although I opted for blue cheese instead of the basil vinaigrette. Ordered the bison NY strip medium rare, parmesan broccoli and the onion rings for dinner. Steak was cooked right, but a little too tough and bland for me. The broccoli tasted good, was a little undercooked for what I expected. The onion rings are good. Wasn't as good as I had hoped, service was great, take my opinions for what they are worth.

Went to Ted’s tonight and tried a bison burger with onion rings and they both tasted pretty good. Shelby was a friendly attentive server to have for my first time visiting! I plan on coming back one day