Tacos Y Mariscos El Compa - Mexican restaurant in Caldwell - 605 N 5th Ave, USA

I normally don't meeting people for the first time at a seafood focused restaurant, but luckily, this place has a lot of nonseafood options that are very good. And of course, if you like seafood, that's very good as well. They don't list individual street tacos on the menu, they have no problem making them individually. Seafood first- the spicy shrimp Taco Ayuyu was delicious. I also ordered two Asada, two Al Pastor, and two carnitas. All of their tacos were very good. The Al pastor was just a touch drier than I would prefer. And the tortillas could use a little more love, just some more time on the grill. But other than that it was a great plate of street tacos. And the salsas and sauces are great. Chips and salsa has some good flavor, the salsa verde is thick and has some taste to it, the red salsa is just a touch sweet and no burnt chipotle flavor. Very good on the asada and seafood. I was very happy with all their food, and the service was fast and friendly.

This place was amazing! The food was delicious 😋. First time trying ostiones razuradas, and they were bomb 💣. The Fish was so juicy, and the coconut 🥥 shrimp 🍤 were mouthwatering. We had sooo much fun there! Really nice place to go to in Idaho. The cantaritos and Micheladas were great! Would definitely go back! Live music kicked everything off!

Hubby had the fish , and I the chicken enchiladas . We also had some tostada de pulpo ( octopus tostada, which was very tender and not rubbery.

I had a rude waitress. She is a bully and made it the worst experience. I love this place and the food is amazing, however I dread walking in and seeing this woman. I’m not sure how to add photos if I did I’d add a picture to show her. beware of this lady.

Outstanding food, great service, drinks were on point. The seafood was fresh, perfectly cooked, came in huge portions, and was super reasonably priced. We got the ceviche tostadas (SO fresh), Camarones con crema (garlicky cheesy creamy heaven), and the camarones Vallarta (perfectly cooked slightly spicy, also heavenly). My boyfriend said the food was just like his moms cooking growing up🤌🏻 A live band started around 6pm which was super rad too. It was a really great experience all around, can’t wait to go back. Took the pics after we started digging in, it smelled too good to wait 😂

Best Mexican seafood around! Staff is super friendly and attentive. Will definitely be going back again. The picture is a mango margarita and a coronita margarita.

Please do not go here. This place is sketchy to say the least. My family and I went here for drinks and drinks only. We were guided to a back room where the TVs were busted, the bathrooms were disgusting, and our waitress was confused to say the least. She took our orders and everyone ordered a margarita except for my pregnant sister in law, who ordered a Shirley temple. When we got our drinks, there was no alcohol to be found, even in the doubles. When we received our receipt and questioned why the Shirley temple was lumped into the “mixed drink” charge, the waitress explained that she served my sister in law a mixed drink. When my SIL questioned if the waitress put alcohol in it, she responded “i don’t know, do you feel drunk?” My SIL informed the waitress that she was pregnant. She did not take it seriously at all and did not know what “mixed drink” meant. Long story short, I’m fairly sure there was no alcohol in the alcoholic drinks and she couldn’t care less that she may or may not have served a pregnant woman alcohol. Screw this place.

If you like the out of the way places for great authentic Mexican food, this is the one! We have become almost weekly regulars here. These folks know what they are doing. We have not been disappointed yet. They are always courteous and welcoming. The food is amazing! We have tried several different dishes and all have been muy Bueno! Would highly recommend stopping in.