Stellina Bakery & Cafe - Bakery and Cake Shop in Syosset - 14 Cold Spring Rd, USA

Good variety of pastries. The coffee isn't bad either. They also have sandwiches.

Thank you so much, Dylan for the amazing cake for my daughter. Not only did it look beautiful but it tasted great. Everyone loved it. We also love the breakfast sandwiches and pastries. Love the atmosphere and staff. They are so helpful and sweet. Thank you!

We love their cakes for special occasions, and I also love getting lunch and coffee at Stellina Bakery & Cafe. As you might imagine, their bread is delicious and often find myself craving their tuna salad sandwich. Like right now! 🤤

Cute cafe. Came here after dinner for some dessert and coffee and tea. They had a wide selection of sandwiches, pastries, cakes, and candy. Hit the spot for our sweet tooth fix

Beautiful inside, welcoming and reasonably priced. But… I got 8 of the mini cakes that are $25/lb. The 8 came up to a lil over $11 which was very fairly priced. Out of the 8 only 3 we’re fresh and the other 5 were very stale and hard.. hard that you cannot bypass it and they had to feel the staleness when they picked it out and still gave it to me. I was very disappointed that the majority of the mini cakes were stale because the 3 that were fresh were really really good. I would give the bakery another try but I would make sure to let them know about my experience and to make sure the cakes are fresh.

Delicious cake, amazing staff - who dealt with my craziness on such short notice. Beautifully decorated and brought such a smile to my 16-year-old daughter's face (which isn't easy😉) Even the restaurant staff was impressed by the taste and texture of the cake. Can't wait to stop in again for a treat or to order another specialty cake.

Our wedding cake came from Stellina‘s. Custom made. Not only a beautiful look, but also the best taste ever for a wedding cake. Perfect balance of cream/custard, light dough, fresh fruits. A delight. All our guests loved it and asked where it was coming from. THANK YOU Stellina’s team.

Strawberry shortcake 8” $38 - 6.5/10 Strawberry filling 10/10, fresh and just right amount of sweetness. Flawless. Frosting 10/10. Fresh, light, right amount of sweetness. Cake layers itself - 6/10. Moderately dry / stale cake. And you can see in the picture, the layers aren’t fluffy, it’s a bit dense and dried. Disappointing, everything executed perfectly except for the cake layers itself. Went here when it was Cardinali 20+ years ago, came back hoping a better cake. Same issue back then. At least they’re consistent dry.