Stefano's Restaurant - Northern Italian restaurant in Pompton Plains - 565 NJ-23, USA

We hosted a private party for my daughter’s baptism in the large dining room. We had about 50 adults and 10 kids. The room was plenty big, food was outstanding (so many guests commented on it as they hadn’t been there before), and we added the gelato bar/cart which was a hit for adults and kids alike. The owners were very accommodating and made the process easy, yet executed perfectly. I couldn’t recommend it more. We plan to host many future parties there going forward.

We just finished up a party of 28 at stefanos and each and every one of our guests were impressed with the food and the service. We opted for one of their party menu options which ended up being perfect and more food than we could have asked for. We were greeted by Robin upon arrival who took care of our entire party from keeping beverages cold, wine bottles open and kids happy. She was phenomenal, professional, and exhibited a calm sense of urgency which impressed our whole party. The food was served timely, hot and of great quality and all of the staff was courteous and prioritized service and cleanliness. I would recommend this restaurant for a small family dinner for good quality food or a large get together in their private room.

My wife and I are regulars at Stefano's. Always a great meal with great service. This past Friday we had our company Holiday Party in the back room. What a great event. The food was amazing(as usual), but the service was even better. The staff was very attentive during setup and Robin was a pleasure to work with. Robin made sure to personally bring out a separate meal for one of our guests with a dietary restriction. I highly recommend Stefano's for a party or just a great night out.

I've dined at Stefanos for many years. The food is absolutely delicious, the friendly staff are efficient, both the restaurant and restrooms are very clean. It is a BYOB restaurant (which is appreciated). and we are never rushed after dinner I also cater food for the Holidays each year, and Our favorite family meal CHICKEN PARM is a MUST to try!!!. I don't know the secret recipe here but you won't be disappointed

We recently had our company dinner at Stefano's Restaurant. We had our own private room with space to get up and walk around if needed. Waitstaff was outstanding! Food was delicious! Everyone who attended our dinner was definitely satisfied with there meal. Stefano's will be on our lists of options for any of our next work functions!!!! I highly recommend!

Our large group was well taken care of. The food was excellent and the servers were attentive. Lou was always taking care of us. She made sure we were not lacking anything. We were also not rushed. We were at the table for over 3 hours. Portions were generous.

Had a baby shower in the side room. The service was very responsive; 3 servers for 32 people. Nice selection of food to be served. The food was served family style with good portions; it was delicious. We had a photographer and were free to take pictures throughout the restaurant area, which was nice.

We hosted our daughter’s baptism on a Saturday evening. The brothers were easy to work with and welcomed my calls, answered my questions and treated us like family! Robin and David were our waiters that night. They went above and beyond the entire night, especially to accommodate our few guests with allergies. By the end of the night, every guest was raving about the service and food. We could not recommend Stefano’s enough!