Stefano's Pizzeria - Pizza restaurant in Pompton Plains - 569 NJ-23, USA

Whether we order pizza or dinner takeout the food is always delicious. We usually order for delivery n the food or pizza comes piping hot n quick. When we dine in we always order dinner food n we always enjoy! Whichever our preference we never are disappointed. We always enjoy the pizza when we order.

I wish that I could give them 10 stars. To say that we had an amazing experience would be understatement. I had a reception dinner for 30 people on 11/14 and Everyone loved not only the food especially the penne with vodka sauce (hands down the best around) but the atmosphere was also great. They made sure that everyone was taken care of right down to the guests allergies which believe me a lot of restaurants are not that considerate when it comes to allergies but Stefano Junior was on top of the situation. I would highly recommend them for any type of event that you are having.

I can’t say enough about Stefano’s , the food is off the charts , closest to homemade without being in your house . If you want just a quick slice or a sit down meal , you won’t disappointed. Started coming here when we moved into the neighborhood 20 years ago , it’s a family atmosphere because it’s family owned and they welcome you in as apart of the family. Come sit down and eat !

I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM THIS PIZZA PLACE AGAIN. I placed an order, for a Large cheese pie & buffalo boneless wings. They give me 4 boneless wings & a barley cooked pizza!!!! HORRIBLE. I talked to the kid Brandon on the phone who ignored everything I said, I asked for the manager & the manage was sarcastic and RUDE. Telling me "we give 5 wings what do you want 50? Saying I been in business for 20+ years. HORRIBLE, terrible terrible. DO NOT GO THERE

We have been to Stefano’s many times for private eating, with our kids, and for events. Every time we have thoroughly enjoyed all aspects of our experience! The staff is amazing and you will never see me turn down one of their cannoli’s! Can’t wait for our next visit!

Just paid 20.00 for grilled chicken over penne with marinara sauce. The sauce was poorly prepared, the penne was super overcooked. I took one bite and asked the server to wrap it up. I paid my tab and tossed the plate in there garbage. The one in front of their door.

This is my lunch spot. I love the special pizzas I can get by the slice. My favorite is portobello, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella. So many great options. Now they have gelato and the cannolis have always been delicious with at least 14 flavor options

I have only had reheated slices of awesome pizza, rice balls, and one plain cannoli here, but I cannot wait to come back to get the full affect with dinner. Always good food and service. Outdoor and indoor dining. They do party events too in a section I have not seen yet.