Scribner's Catskill Lodge - Hotel in Hunter - 13 Scribner Hollow Rd, USA

Lovely stay! Stayed in the lofted queen bedroom with the fireplace. The fireplace really made the room cozy. The lofted area allows you to keep the bed separate from the living area which was great for us. If you’re very tall it might be challenging to do the loft but should be fine on the side with the higher roof. On site there’s yoga in the morning, movies on weekends and evenings, and a sauna plus seasonal ice rink or pool. Lounge has a really nice vibe with a fireplace, seating, books, and a pool table. I loved the number of fireplaces throughout the entire property. Plus the views of Hunter mountain. Prospect, the restaurant on site, is good. The food is a little expensive, especially for breakfast, so I recommend getting some in from the pantry or down the road at Fellow for morning bites. They make great cocktails which you can enjoy in the hotel lounge if you want.

We’ve been coming here for a few years now and it’s always a magical experience! The rooms are comfy, cute and have beautiful views. The service is always excellent, and if we ever visit for a special occasion they make us feel special. This has become me and my husbands most looked forward to trip year in and year out!

Had a great long weekend stay here but probs won’t be back. Beautiful view from the room however everything felt lower budget than I would have expected for the price. Strange smell from the heater/ac. Bedding was comparable to a Hyatt or Residence Inn. Dismissive service from the front desk. The main lobby with the fireplace looks beautiful but all the furniture is pretty uncomfortable so not great for hanging out. Outdoor property was gorg. Love that it’s dog friendly. Restaurant staff was super friendly and helpful too!

I'm an MUA, and have traveled to this lodge a few times to get guests& newlyweds ready for weddings. The rooms are lovely, and the grounds are absolutely beautiful. My clients and I love coming here :)

Unfortunately the accommodation for the wheelchair wasn't up to par.. the wheelchair doesn't completely fit and towels for the floor were hard to come by. I struggled with doors and luggage and no help was given.... coffee was cold and I was glad to leave... nice idea but not there yet. Room wasn't super clean and no place to put clothes or personal items... felt a little like an upscale holiday inn. Great that is was dog friendly but the dog next door was barking every time the owner left.

I surprised my partner with a birthday trip to this wonderful hotel. The staff's exceptional hospitality and assistance throughout our stay truly made the weekend unforgettable. The special touches of a handwritten birthday note & ice cream and candle sent to the room really were above and beyond. A heartfelt thank you to Scribners for creating such a special experience. Also, obsessed with Andrew’s garden tour- what a treasure! Looking forward to returning and bringing our beloved pups along next time!

My second stay, but I don’t think I’ll be back - its lost its touch as a Catskills destination. The food was bland, boring, and overpriced for the lack of quality. The staff was friendly, but coming from hospitality, there’s a clear disconnect. Doesn’t feel cozy and inviting like make other hotels in the area. The rooms are really stripped down and simple, comfy beds but no real vibe in my opinion. It’s a beautiful location so I hope they do a glow up soon because they need it.

My husband and I spent a few days at Scribner's right after our wedding. It was the perfect setting for a "mini moon" -- our room was spacious (and the bed was super comfortable) and we really enjoyed all of the activities we could do on site, whether that was swimming and reading by the pool, having nightly sauna sessions, playing billiards, or getting a fabulous dinner at Prospect. We also enjoyed the nightly bonfires and the complimentary s'mores kits the hotel provided. Additionally, it has great proximity to the cute shops and restaurants in Tannersville (and is not far from Hudson) as well as awesome hikes and other outdoor activities. I wholeheartedly recommend Scribner's the next time you're looking to plan a vacation or getaway weekend to the Catskills!