Sayville Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Pizza restaurant in Sayville - 60 Main St, USA

I ordered delivery on the slice app. We got a coupon deal which was a large pie, wings, garlic knots and a 2 liter of soda for 31.95. The delivery was on time and the food was hot. The pizza and wings were pretty good. I was not a fan of the garlic knots, they were a little tough. Overall a good experience and I would order from again.

Do not order from these people. They will take your money, then give you the run around for an hour before telling you that the store is closed at 5pm and there's nothing they can do for you. They honestly expect us to believe that the store was closed at 5pm, despite the order being confirmed AND money being withdrawn from my account. We've been ordering from them on and off for years and it's never been anything but a headache. The pizzas also mediocre at best. Don't waste your time or money or patience on these people. Edit to add: since the owner would like to reply with bullcrap excuses that I can't reply to.. I live in West Sayville. Internet been fine all day long and no one else I know in Sayville has had a problem at all. Matter of fact, I used my internet to order from them. Then they took money from my account through the internet, and CONFIRMED MY ORDER through the internet! So, try again, bud. Now we know you're a liar as well as a thief. Cool.

I heard this establishment was under new owners so thought id give a carry out a try... My review is on the Pepperoni pizza alone. you can tell a lot about a pizza place through its Pepperoni pizza. The pizza was fair, however the taste of Pepperoni on the pizza was almost overpowering. Tasted like those frozen pizzas you can get at a supermarket with the Pepperoni ontop and the little Pepperoni squares in the sauce. Other then that the pizza ate like a pizza. Wouldn't recommend Pepperoni pizza here, but hey, what do I know.

Above average regular pizza. Some really nice specialty pizzas, and incredible garlic knots. This place is just good all around. The delivery drivers are always quick, as well!

Sorry one of the worst sauces I have ever had it was so watered down I just moved into the neighborhood so I wanted to try it never again no flavor at all.

Great spot. We like how they re-did it! It's cool, fresh and the kids liked it too!!

Haven't been back to this place in years. Dorothy our server was fabulous. We ordered pizza which was good. We ordered calamari as an appetizer, a little disappointed there was no tentacles. Lasagna was good but I like to see a nice square of lasagna. All in all I would go back. Just to see Dorothy and chat with her.

I moved to the area recently and recieved a coupon in the mail for a free cheese pie to try out from this pizzeria. I finally used it today and ordered a cheese pie, zucchini sticks, garlic knots and a house salad. Everything was delicious! The pizza was hot and delicious, fresh, and the salad dressing was SO good. I'm so glad they sent this in the mail or else I wouldn't have even known about the pizzeria. I can't wait to come back.