Sarabeth's - Brunch restaurant in New York - 423 Amsterdam Ave, USA

One of the best breakfast places over tried so far. The food is amazing and there’s no way to describe how good it is. Everything we got tasted perfect and very well made. The only bad thing is: everything is very expensive in Manhattan, I get it. The food was totally worth the price so it was not a problem. But when it comes to the orange juice that’s where I see there’s something wrong. $12 a glass of orange juice that is not even fresh and squeezed at the moment. I’m very picky when it comes to that and I definitely know when an orange juice is fresh squeezed, but paying $12 for a glass where you can see they pouring it in a cup from a gallon is very disappointing. Many places (most of them) serve artificial orange juice. I get it. But they have a different price for that. All my experience in going out for brunch or breakfast where I ordered orange juice, I never paid that much for an artificial one. So this is the only crazy thing I saw and I experienced. I would definitely go back but not ordering the orange juice again. Overall, everything was perfect and tasty.

I would give the omelette (3.5/5) and pancakes (3/5). The omlette was cooked nicely and had a tasty side of jam and butter, but the omelette itself lacked seasoning. and The avocado's texture was liquidy and lacked seasoning (1.5/5). The french toast was a bit oily and you could feel the taste of the eggs - wasn't very nice (1/5). Food was mostly bland, unfortunately. There may be better orders, but based on my experience, I wouldn't go back.

Very first experience of discriminatory service in NYC. We made a reservation and I arrived 5 minutes earlier than my friend. The lady in red sweater told me that they can’t give a table until the other party arrived and added that they will only reserve it for 15 minutes in a condescending manner. Later we found they gave tables to whomever arrived first twice (we heard that they made a reservation too). Not only that, the waiter serving us only explained that there are two options for toast to the other table, which he didn’t for us. Coincidentally I am East Asian, my friend is South Asian, and all the other ladies who received different services were White Americans. We wanted to celebrate new year with a nice brunch and it ended up a horrendous experience. Regardless we left generous tips for them not to extend that kind of behaviors to other Asians visiting this store, and it felt very bitter.

I'm glad to heaI recently visited Sarabeth's Bakery on Amsterdam Avenue, and I must say it was a truly delightful experience. We enjoyed top-tier Bloody Marys with unique garnishes like bacon and shredded pickled carrots. I opted for the Eggs Benedict, which were absolutely delicious, and my companions tried the mouthwatering Lemon and Ricotta Pancakes and Avocado Toast. The staff was fantastic, making our visit even more enjoyable. If you're in NYC and looking for a great brunch spot, Sarabeth's Bakery is a must-visit. Highly recommended!

Sarabeth's brunch: a heavenly start to the weekend! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ From the fluffy French toast that practically melted in my mouth to the perfectly poached eggs and rich Hollandaise on the steak Benedict, Sarabeth's brunch was a symphony of flavors that truly hit the spot. Every bite was pure deliciousness, and the fresh, quality ingredients shone through. But beyond the food, it was the service that truly elevated the experience. Dago took exceptional care of us, with attentiveness and warmth that made us feel like valued guests. We left feeling happy, satisfied, and already planning our next return. If you're looking for a brunch that's as delicious as it is welcoming, Sarabeth's is a must-try!

I haven't explored numerous brunch destinations in New York City, but Sarabeth's, situated on the Upper West Side, marked my inaugural experience. My husband and I opted for a brunch outing, and I must say, it exceeded my expectations. The buttermilk pancakes and crispy chicken sandwich we selected were a delight. Accompanied by their timeless mimosa and a passionista, our meal was thoroughly enjoyable. If you find yourself uncertain about where to indulge in brunch, I wholeheartedly recommend giving this establishment a try

Their signature burger was good, although nothing special. I asked to sit at a different seat, and the host told me that it was reserved. But then another table was allowed to move to the exact seat we wanted. ?

Came here for brunch with my friend. This brunch overall was just okay for me. The food wasn’t really unforgettable, the service could’ve been better (as in nicer) and the overall atmosphere didn’t really impact me enough into wanting to return. I had the popovers dish, specifically the “wild mushroom scramble” popovers. It was quite a large portion I’ll say, which is a big plus for me. I could taste the boursin cheese, which I liked. The popover itself, I would not order again. I chose it, because I had never had it before, but the popover lacked flavor and crunch for me. Regarding the service, due to my friend being late, we lost my reservation seats, but we were lucky to get seated at the bar. The waiter who initially came to us, was sort of rude to my friend. He asked if we knew what we wanted to drink, to which she kindly answered “not yet, but we know what we would like to order to eat”. She and I are used to waiters always being very welcome to take our food order in such a scenario, but this waiter reacted quite snappy and said “well I asked drinks only”. This was not customer friendly, he could’ve responded in a more friendly manner. Thankfully the waiter who was stationed behind the bar assisted us throughout the remainder of our brunch. He on the other hand was very kind! To me Sarabeth doesn’t really stand out, but that doesn’t mean that it’s not worth a try or that it’s not a good restaurant.