Sals Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Italian restaurant in New Holland - 920 W Main St, USA

The grandma pizza is delicious, the owner really cares about his ingredients and it shows. One of the better pizzas I've had in lancaster County. Beutiful undercarriage, delicious sauce and real thin crust.

Good 🍕. Clean establishment. Soda from the soda dispenser did have an odd taste. Perhaps it was the ice. Late lunch was yummy.

Perfect flavor, perfect portion size, perfect service and this place should be packed! Ample eat in area, quick to go service as well , plus they have a drive thru! Plenty of different pizzas, salads, hoagies and subs and more. The value you get is perfect. The flavor of my Buffalo chicken salad was amazing! Easy no frills place, perfect for lunch and dinner. I'll be a regular from now on. 👍

Sub-par pizzeria, flavor profile is very simplistic, nothing stands out and makes your taste buds jump for joy. It will do the trick in a pinch but for the price point I was hoping for much more. On a better note the customer service was very good and the interior of the restaurant was very tidy.

The person taking order was on the phone with someone while taking order. Very impersonal. The warmed up pizza did not taste fresh and the bottom of it tasted burnt. There were tables thru out that were not cleaned, with trash from previous customers. And to top it off, I was shorted a few dollars in change. Won't be going back. It's a shame,because I used to like the pizza and atmosphere.😔 We were going to dine in until we saw the condition of the eat in area.

Went here on October 27th .Ordered rigatoni with meat sauce. The sauce was completely WATERED down and barely looked like Sauce. The Rigatoni was over cooked. The only good thing was the Waitress. She was WONDERFUL. The employees CLAIM to be Italian. You would NEVER Know it. WON'T be returning.

Gave 3 stars because my review is mixed - full disclosure I grew up in Brooklyn NY and have been to Italy many times so I may be spoiled - got a hero half meatball half sausage all parmesan- the meatballs were good - not the best I ever had but definitely not the worst - the sausage was basically shaved - just paper thin slices of sausage that wasn't particularly tasty and had more pepper and onion than sausage- decent amount of cheese. Service was friendly. If I go back for a hero it will just be meatball hero. I don't see how that sausage would even be good on pizza. Just fry up real sausage and cut it into coins.

A friend and I were out for the day and stop to get some dinner . Never there before. We had to order at counter and felt extremely rushed. The guy seemed aggravated because we didn't order quick enough.(NEver seen the menu before so we needed time. The only person that was plesant was the GENTLEMAN that brought our food .When we sat down we had no utensils and our drinks were not brought to our table. . To me my dinner was horrible my shells were swimming in what seemed like just tomatoes .had absolutely no flavor at all. . If it wasn't so expensive I would have left it there. The only thing good was the salad. Never again will I go there. And the man behind the counter needs an attitude adjustment..