Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern - American restaurant in Hilliard - 3901 Britton Pkwy, USA

Amazing Cheesesteak. Good size and great taste. Lots of cheese which I haven't really seen before, but enjoyed. Our server—and I'm afraid I've forgotten his name but he was bald with a beard and maybe some tattoos— was also very fun. Beer prices were decent, definitely lower than some other places I've been.

The food was good, better than we expected coming for the first time out of town. The table next to us, were rowdy and kept yelling, and none of the staff did anything about it. Our server was pleasant, but not over doing herself or even tried to chat or be friendlier, so not sure what that was about. She kept our drinks refilled, but like, I asked for ketchup for my fries and she set it next to my friend's nachos? Didn't make sense to do that.

Our first visit to this place. We do not drink, so anytime we go to a tavern we are not sure what to expect from the food. We got the fried pickle spears as an appetizer, they were delicious. I absolutely loved the glazed salmon, it was delicious. My wife enjoyed the philly steak and cheese and the fries were very good. The waitress was excellent and responsive, we lacked nothing. Thank you Rusty Bucket, we will be returning customers.

A very good experience. Food was great, service was excellent, and the cost is very reasonable. Pumpkin Cheese Cake is off the charts great

Burger was good although very moist / wet which was a bit of a let down. The Quesadilla and kids meals were decent. However the chicken finger remained virtually untouched due to the breading being very wet/slimy. Server was nice, but no utensils on the table and never came back around once food was delivered.

The selection of offerings is small. Nothing stands out about the restaurant and the food is overpriced compared to similar fare elsewhere. Service has generally been okay. Best part about it is there has never been much of a wait to be seated and served. My daughter really likes their bacon cheeseburger with gluten free bun and yhe chicken parm is good.

We had a large party, 20+ which reservations were reserved . I only seen 1 waitress , if there was a second one helping I never seen her . Our food took longer , which was expected because how big the group was , but when it came out it was cold. We had to send some back for them to put in the microwave. Kicker , half our party barely made it home, the food didn’t settle with our stomachs. People were up majority of the night in the bathroom. It was horrible !

The Mediterranean salad was amazing! I was surprised it was so big, I was expecting something way smaller! The menu is hilarious! Loving the names of the foods. Let’s not forget how awesome our waiter was, she was very friendly, very warming and I would be more than happy to revisit and hopefully next time have room for sweets!