RigaTony’s Pizza & Pasta - Pizza restaurant in Lancaster - 5009 Ave L-14, USA

0/0 stars if I could. I do not review places often but the pizza I got was so terrible, I am still shocked. I ordered a regular buffalo chicken pizza and did not get that. First the pizza was soggy, I felt the box and it was moist but I assumed the pizza was just hot. Turns out it was still raw and lukewarm. To make matters worse they added pineapples, ranch, and peppered buffalo sauce. EXTREMELY BAD AND DISAPPOINTING! I ordered from here all the time as a kid but clearly something has changed since. Sad it didn't live up to my memories, do not go here.

Hands down best pizza and italian in Av. Super friendly staff and very fast if you pick up. Delivery is a tad longer the place is packed every night, that should tell you how popular they are. But still serve it up fast. I worked on pizza places as a kid, they use quality ingredients. So good. 5 star all the way

If you are tired of eating those nasty big pizza chains and want a real pizza this is the place. We take the 25 min drive to get our fix. We typically order the same pizza and its always consistent. If you haven't tried this place is definitely worth giving it a shot.

Nice place, good prices, good food, good atmosphere. The lunch special is nice. Would definitely recommend to anyone around 10/10 fire. - Rating on behalf of 4 friends

Pass by this charming little spot all the time but we never knew it was a pizza/pasta place till the local fliers had an ad for it that we saw. Came in for a pizza, they were done in less than 10 minutes and came outside in the cold to find us, my wife and I loved it. The pizza was nice and hot, TONS of cheese, and very tasty! Can't wait to come back and try their subs and meatballs. And MAN it smells so good in there!

Tried RigaTony's Pizza & Pasta today for our family of 5. We spent $75.00 including tax and tip for 1 medium cheese pizza, 1 medium pepperoni pizza, 1 medium meatball sub, 1 three topping calzone, 1 order of fries, 2 orders of cannoli and 2 large fountain drinks. We did carry out so we could eat in front of our tv and watch some movies together. My review: THE CUSTOMER SERVICE WAS 10/10!!!! The pizza was good! way better than the chains. Our kids loved the regular crust. The dough was perfect! The sub was a bit dry but could be because we asked for light sauce. The meatballs were delicious and had good seasoning on them. Unfortunately the calzone was very bland, the was good but very plain like maybe they should spread some garlic butter on the top or some type of seasoning in the dough, I thought maybe it was because of the olives because my toppings were olives, pepperoni and sausage but even eating the toppings individually.. just no flavor so I spruced it up with Italian seasoning, some Parmesan and dipped it in the marinara sauce and it was really tasty like that. The cannoli was perfect like if you ever want to pick up dessert and are craving cannoli, this is where you should get it from. The fries had too much seasoning on them so the kids wouldn’t eat them but we did, I thought they should just put salt instead. Fountain drinks good as well, perfect amount of syrup and perfect amount of burn! We definitely will be back to try other items. I’m interested in some of their appetizers, salads and pasta! I recommend trying them if you haven’t!

11/16/23: sometimes you find a place VIA a "super high" rating here on Google maps and the place exceeds that "high expectation", RigaTony's is a perfect example of this. We visit this area quite often due to some things we have around. Since most of the time they are earlier in the day, we usually stop at Sagebrush across the street for some coffee. Having noticed the small sign on the main road pointing the way, 1st chance we had for an evening visit here for an event we took a chance and came here. This place did not in anyway dissapoint. It's essentially an "East Coast Style Take Out" Italian place, which is awesome to see round here as I am from back east. The food was well made, large portion, fair prices and super tasty. My wife got a combo calzone and I got a White Knight which turned out be be a really great choice. No seats inside, but does have 3 tables outside to sit and eat if you are so inclined as we were this evening. Staff was very nice and very patient while ordering and this leads me to what probably surprised me the most... Speed of service to quality of food. It took under 15 minutes to order and get our choices. I mention this because from the time we walked in through the time we got the order until after eating in front and leaving? It was a river of both phone calls while inside and a deluge of people coming and going. For a place to be constantly taking orders be it via phone or internet as well as walk ins to have gotten food so quickly, and food that tasted top notch isn't as easy as people may perceive. It impressed us to see this place firing on all gears. So it really isn't surprising why you see such a high rating here on Google maps for RigaTony's. Everything was A+. The wife and I are now planning to make this a regular evening stop when we are out this way and while RigaTony's is open, both open in a time of day and open in a business sense. I will add also, there is a chain pizza place across the way, and I'm frankly shocked at how they stay in business so close to RigaTony's; I really can't imagine someone choosing chain pizza when this place is a stones throw away. What is also super cool? They have a front window where you can peek in and see the food going through the pizza oven. I found this to be a really neat and fun choice to have this be something one could do while waiting for take out! My only suggestion for RigaTony? Light up the sign on the corner so more people just driving by could come and indulge in your tasty food!

This place used to be great but over the last several years has been inconsistent and on the decline. Pizza crust was flat and sloppy, toppings were falling off. The taste and quality isn’t there any more. This happened to me the last time I had them and thought it was a one off, but when I happened again. I decided to post because for the cost of their pizza and their history I expect better. Be warned it’s not the best or even close pizza quality was like a bad $5 little Cesar’s pizza for 3x the price.