Reikart House, Buffalo, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel - Hotel in Amherst - 5000 Main St, USA

A new hotel in historical style & they nailed. The attention to detail was excellent. Great beds. Very pet friendly hotel with the front desk spoiling Milo with a cookie every time we walked by the front desk. Breakfast was excellent. Excellent food at the restaurant with great cocktails & live music.

This is my third review and I will only say that it continues to maintain its high standards for expert service, immaculate grounds, and beautiful and comfortable rooms. The shower, as I have mentioned many times, cannot be bettered. A wonderful hotel to return to time and again. The only caveat is that even-numbered rooms look onto the parking lot behind the hotel. This can be uncomfortable if you're on the first floor as you will have to keep privacy in mind at all times. Second floor rooms may overlook parking but you have more privacy.

For me personally, the price of $550+ once converted to Canadian dollars just doesn’t add up. Not comparable with other hotels in the area, especially with no breakfast inclusion and no pool. The hotel itself is pretty, but on the smaller side. The rooms are also nice, but wouldn’t say for the value they are on par. Pricing like this I could book almost book the Ritz in Toronto. Basic toiletries also not provided that other hotels provide, I.e. makeup wipes and shoe shine kits. Washroom doesn’t have enough counter space to hold any of your personal belongings. Towels are kept in the main room also, as no shelving is available to place them in the washroom. Weird concept for a “4 star” hotel. Breakfast was also not included. Front staff could also be a bit more friendlier. EDIT: we would never return. The price may be comparable, however, for less services and amenities.

I've stayed in hotels (VERY FANCY, EX: Ritz in Singapore, Westin in Perth, Australia, Grand Hyatt in New York City,) throughout the world since 1966 and I will put Reikart House as #2 on my list of elegance, charm and overall top class. Front desk personnel are awesome, the cleanliness of the rooms is superb. Anyone staying in this area is highly encouraged to stay at the Reikart House. We travel to this area a couple of times a year and have always stayed at other hotels in the area, but they have changed some of their policies that did not sit well with us. So I looked around and found Reikart House, read the reviews and booked our stay and we're very pleased that we stayed here and will again. THIS HOTEL IS A CLASS ACT!

Very nice hotel, clean, friendly, very good sized room, cleaning was second to none. Great parking availability, super quiet rooms, easy highway access with many services and restaurants very close by. The hotel is great. However I can't say the same for the breakfast they serve. Our eggs were luke warm at best, my wife's were cooked to death, fruit dish was way past its prime (we couldn't eat it) and our server had an attitude. Don't bother eating breakfast here, there are way better options down the street.

Awesome hotel located close to airport, restaurants, and bars. There’s a jazz restaurant and bar located right next door. Free parking located in the front and around back. Service was great and friendly. They do have a gym located onsite. They offer the most delicious cookies in the evenings. Rooms are super comfortable, and they also have a shared common area up front that is super nice. I recommend staying here.

Stayed one night and it was one of the most beautiful/clean places iv been. The man at the desk checking us in was professional and so incredibly caring. Offering us fresh baked cookies and bottles of water. The room was great but the bottles of shampoo and body wash were empty. The room temp was also set to 74 when we arrived and on a hot summer day it was roasting. We turned it down and turned the air on but it took over 5 hours just to reach 70. By the time we left in the morning it still wasn’t where we wanted it. We were about to leave our room and check out when there was a knock on our door, it was a housekeeper asking us when we were going to check out, we still had time before checkout time so I very confused and felt rushed. Overall great stay and would stay again!

Stayed one night when driving through buffalo. It’s a small independent hotel, clean, very comfy bed. The price only get you a room, no complimentary breakfast. Made to order menu is quite pricy, there is no other facilities other than a gym ( I didn’t use) either. The lobby is beautiful but no lounge service on Saturday night, no bars. You can dine in restaurant next door. Bath gel bottle was empty, but they quickly delivered a new bottle to the room. I feel with a luxury rating hotel shouldn’t let guest to call for bath gel. The complimentary toothbrush has very poor quality, doesn’t match to the price of the hotel room. Ok for one night, won’t return though . With the price you can easily stay in a luxury hotel with much more to offer.