Pizza Plus - Pizza restaurant in Cadillac - 302 N Mitchell St, USA

I’m a Grand Rapids local visiting the area for business. I was looking for a quality pizza parlor and believe I found the best in the area. I ordered the cheesy bread with olives and it was reasonably priced, had fresh ingredients, and was timely for pick up. My only criticism would be that they don’t offer delivery and that their hours don’t accommodate late night meals. The next time I’m in town, my goal is to try to original sub. Update to follow.

Pizza was delicious and the prices more than fair. Folks working were super friendly as well. We are so happy we stopped on our way through town…we’ll definitely be back!

Great tasting pizzas, although the kids tend to center load them (as seen in the pic). The original sub is the best sandwich in Cadillac. Good prices. I don’t eat here enough.

Talk about a hidden gem! Granted, the place isn't hidden but it's not talked about as much as it deserves! This family is on its third generation owning the business, the pizza and bread sticks were PHENOMENAL and the price was great! We will be returning to try the subs next! YUM YUM FULL TUMMY!!

We ordered takeout for the first time at Pizza Plus. It was some of the best pizza I’ve had! The pizza was piping hot when we picked it up and it was cooked to perfection. The cheese had a nice caramelization. We will definitely get it again.

We tried their pizza Saturday night. The place is hopping busy for a reason. The pizza was fantastic!!! The service was friendly, with an honest estimated wait time. It’s been a long time since we have had pizza this good (like pizza we had as kids in the 70’s). And bonus, it was not expensive. We will be returning!

Did not expect much from this small place but everything we ordered was excellent! Delicious pizza, salad, and wet burrito! The folks running this place are super friendly, and the prices are great.

Pizza Plus is a favorite of the Cadillac Area. After looking at some photos online, I finally decided to give it a try. I ordered a large Pepperoni pizza, with extra cheese. A pizza pocket with sausage, Pepperoni, green pepper, and onion. Finally two orders of their garlic Cheese bread. I was told it would be 35 minutes. So we went to pick it up. It was almost an hour before the order was ready. When I opened the pizza box it was a wet swamp of cheese! I am a cheese lover. It all looked delicious to me! At home I first tried the garlic cheese bread. It is definitely delicious. A 10/10. Everyone agreed on that. The pizza is another story. Even as a cheese lover, I'm telling you that you don't need that extra cheese . It made the thin crust soggy. The sauce and Pepperoni flavors were very unappealing. To much seasoning. Very overwhelmed with oregano. This pizza tastes very close to mall/fair pizza. It is a shame to me because the thin crust, if cooked a bit more, could make an amazing pizza with some lighter tomato sauce, and a bit better ingredients. The pizza pocket was the same situation. Overwhelmed With the sauce and Pepperoni flavors. I could not stomach it. The crust was very buttery and delicious, but could have been more well done as well.. The pocket itself was a good size. Compared with other places in town, the prices are pretty reasonable. I have tried the original sub many years ago. It was a 7/10. I personally won't choose pizza from here again.