Pizza Man Trattoria Italiano - Pizza restaurant in Pompton Plains - 574 Newark Pompton Turnpike #5, USA

We had our daughter’s second birthday party here. The kids got to make their own pizzas and it was a hit, but more importantly the pizza and service were great. We have been coming for dinner here for years to enjoy the spectacular food and look forward to continuing to do so! Thank you pizza man!

I went to eat here with my gf after playing soccer and training. The lady wit the blonde hair didn’t know the price for hawaian pizza so she asked the guy. Then he does the math and some how it comes out to 22 dollars for 4 slices of pizza, one lemonade and one Diet Coke. The lady’s reaction was like this 😳😱. I’m not sure how much the lemonade was or the Diet Coke because it’s doesn’t tell you. I don’t know if it’s like local lemonade and that’s why it cost so much but I liked the environment. It was nice and classy and very calm but I still can’t believe I spent 26 dollars for 4 slices and two drinks. On a sign outside it says I can get a 2 whole pie for 20 dollars. 😐 but I didn’t know I was better off ordering the pies because I thought the pizza was like 1-2 dollars per slice. I’m pretty bummed out 😕🫤 No hard feelings though. Just that the prices need to improve a bit. Because in like NY/NJ a slice of pizza can be as low as 99¢

Had some of the best mussels marinara I have ever had. Generous portions, great pricing and phenomenal service above all. They went above and beyond. Will definitely return and would definitely recommend!

Used to come here years ago and wanted to try it again. Does not seem to be nearly as good as it used to be. First, the waiter was good, and very friendly, so service wise, no problems. Got the Chicken Milanese which normally comes with arugula, but unfortunately they did not get any in their shipment that day. Rather than asking if a different green was acceptable, they just made it with iceberg and other greens. It was good, but it would have been better with arugula and I should have been able to decide if I wanted it without arugula. Also got shrimp parm, which happens to be my favorite meal to get in a pizzeria / restaurant. This shrimp parm was hands down the worst I have ever had. I personally didn't like the sauce at all, and the shrimp were so overcooked they were hard. Big disappointment. Oh, and by the way, the bathroom was disgusting, and I had to ask for paper towels. It clearly had not been maintained in quite some time! YUK! Hopefully they keep their kitchen much cleaner!

This is place is a great little hidden gem! BYOB spot! The food is delicious! Tonight we had the eggplant rollitini, the parm crusted chicken in a lemon butter sauce and the chicken francese. Everything was really delicious! We will def be ordering out and dining in again!

My sister and I were in town for a visit to the apothecary and found this place by chance...so glad we did! Food was delicious and very fresh! Will come back with a good bottle of wine next time!

We had my daughter's 1st birthday party here and we all had a great time. The food and service were both excellent.

These people are so friendly & their pizza is by far the best! I've made different pizzas at home & im learning about different types of flour. I asked the owner once about his ingredients, esp the flour because the crust is spot on. I was familiar with the brand of flour they use & it's top notch premium & very expensive. They'll only use a certain brand of quality tomatoes that are shipped in from a company in California, & they only use whole milk mozzarella. I learned from him that when pizza has burn marks on top, it's because the cheese is low grade, part skim...so it tends to burn easily, & then I started to realize how many pizzas I've had from other places in the past with burn marks were a result of low quality ingredients. Never had that when I eat their pizza, and now I know why I love their pizza so much!!