Pizza Crime - Pizza restaurant in Haddonfield - 139 Kings Hwy E, USA

Wow this pizza is amazing from the fresh and well balanced ingredients to the amazing crust and sauce. I couldn’t get enough of it. I’ll definitely be coming back to try the calzone and other pizza options. I got the pepperoni and the mushroom one and wow both options were great.

Look just order their pizza. They aren’t rated #1 for no reason. When in the mood for pizza, which is everyday… I know to order my favorite Pepper Jawny with hot honey.

My wife heard great things about this place, so we went and tried 3 of their pizzas. Don't believe the hype. 1) Too expensive...$15 per 12" pie! 2) All 3 were mostly burnt underneath. 3) Simply, just not good pizza. The service was great, and it is BYOB, so there was that. Will not return, unfortunately.

Great wood-fired pizza place in downtown Haddonfield. As a pepperoni fan, I love their Pepper-Jawnie. I also like their service - I was at nearby King's Road Brewing Company and stopped in to order a pizza, and said I'd come back to pick it up, and they said they would bring it over to the brewery when it was ready. Looking forward to trying more of their pizzas. 😋🍕

An amazing south jersey gem!! Pizza was soooooo so good. Cooked to perfection! And you can tell all the ingredients were so fresh! I was so full on the first pie but wanted to order 2 more because of how good they are. Highly recommend this place if you like high grade Neapolitan style pizza. The waitress did a great job as well and the music was top tier. Really just an all around great place. Hats off to the owner, you created a great thing.

Pretty good pizza. Your standard Neopolitan pizza. A little expensive for the size and quality. Got the margherita and the Finley. Disappointed they didn’t have the wings as the oven was broken. Service was odd. Waitress was nice but forgot ice for our drinks and left us waiting a bit when the restaurant was completely empty. I also don’t usually comment on non-food but the music was so loud and awful. It was a bad playlist of songs you’d hear at a stadium like Get Ready for This. Odd for a small pizza place. My dad had them lower it but we were close to just leaving.

So good. Favorite is the fig pizza. Please never discontinue it. I come here just for that. But not sure why the crust was so big this time. Still amazing but it should go back to how it was originally in terms of size and area of toppings the pizza usually covers. Thank you. Keep up the great work. Update 12/21/23: Today we called a few times to make an order over the phone because for some reason the fig-jawn pizza was taken off from the the online menu a long time ago and usually I used to call to order it, but today it automatically keeps going to voicemail and says they are too busy to pick up. So firstly I couldn’t order the fig jawn pizza and had to make an online order and then when we arrived there 15 min later it is completely empty (not a single other customer is in there). And they said they still haven’t started making the pizza because of the time given in the online order— I didn’t set any pick up time but it automatically gave a 30 min later pick up time in the online ordering system? 1. Why is the fig-jawn not on the online menu? Why can’t it just say it’s sold out if it is not available for the rest of the day then the customer can know? 2. Why is there no phone service available when the restaurant is literally empty of customers? It was definitely not too busy even though the auto recorded message said they are too busy to pick up the phone. 3. The fig jawn pizza is the best (vegetarian) pizza and for that alone this review used to have 5 stars. Today we tried the tuna, shroom, and 4 cheese pizza and the only one we would order again in the future is the 4 cheese. I haven’t tried any meat pizza since I can’t have those here (I can have seafood). 4. The tuna pizza was made well and nicely in all ways except that it barely has any tuna and it was overly salty to the point of being slightly bitter. The potential is there but right now it’s kind of unpleasant to eat. 5. The shroom pizza was good but it could be better. The mushrooms are really good but the cheese that is used for some reason doesn’t really go that well with the mushrooms. I would modify the cheese for da shroom pizza. Maybe a different set of toppings can go better with this cheese and be a new summer pizza. 6. Sorry for the frustration in this review. Hope that some of the feedback can be helpful to make some future changes. I hope the 5 star menu item can be part of the menu again and there can be a solution for the current lack of ways to order it. Thank you. We want this to be our favorite pizza place in NJ, maybe even the country!

Incredibly charming ✔️ Friendly atmosphere ✔️ Fresh ingredients ✔️ I would recommend Pizza Crime to all lovers of pizza. Their menu is limited but well balanced as they knock it out of the park with everyone. There wood fired oven elevates the thin crust. A huge thank you to the entire staff & owner. You have a beautiful vision here.