Pizza Cottage, 23401 US-23, Circleville, OH 43113, United States
Geo Location
Lat long (39.5888099,-82.9546058)
Pizza Cottage - Featured Reviews (992)
Wife and I have ordered before and actually went into the restaurant itself on Thurs for lunch when we were originally coming in Friday night with my inlaws... But you know, snow.
We had such a wonderful time. The food was awesome and Logan treated us so wonderfully. Thank you for everything.
Ordered a pepperoni and cheese pizza too bad they forgot to put cheese on half the pizza and really skimped out on the pepperoni. I usually don’t go here anymore their pizza has really been lacking lately. I normally drive to Lancaster there pizzas are so much better. Quality in Circleville is seriously lacking
First time dining here, and I was not disappointed. Friendly staff, great service, nice environment, and the pizza was delicious. Prices were a bit high, but that's to be expected these days. Will definitely be coming back. Highly recommend.
Went here for a late lunch and had cheesy bread (a must at any pizza place) and pepperoni and sausage pizza and it was delicious and came out very quickly.
Katie was our server and she was friendly and efficient.
We'll be back for sure 😊!
I ordered a medium pepperoni, onion and extra cheese. Just under 17 dollars. Estimated time was 20 minutes and received it during that time. Thin crust, nice and crispy. You could tell it definitely had extra cheese. They add a very nice amount of toppings. It was delicious. This was very greasy though. Dripping down your hand greasy.
Pizza is tasty but pricey. We had the "All the way" 14" and a 14" pepperoni for $40. Logan did provide friendly service. The pizza was ready when we arrived, and was fresh.
Good pizza and a fresh, nice size side salad.
Ordered lg thin crust pep&cheese add cheddar well done not burnt. By far one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time. Debating on ordering another for later.
Great pizza! If you want quality food that taste's good and will actually be good when you come back to it for leftovers, come here. These guys know what they are doing
Oh, yeah, let me tell you about my epic night at Shifty's in Circleville! Ooh, brother, when I strolled in from the darkness, I was greeted by the warm, friendly staff who were so proud of their city, you could feel the love in the air! They welcomed
My boys love this place chasing each other around, then cooling down in large concrete tunnel. Water station for dogs outside fenced area. Nice asphalt trail to walk them. Nice place!
This is probably the best Roosters in the greater central Ohio area. Never had such high quality food from any other location. The head cook this afternoon is a beast, bartender is great, and the servers never keep food in the window. Top notch estab
We were traveling from Columbus to Southern Ohio/ West Virginia... We order 60 some White castles and the staff and employees were more than
Accommodating and patient in the food was delish!! â¥ï¸
From urgent care to the library from getting a hot lunch from one of the many foodtrucks That freak with a location. And even being able to work off those extra calories from lunch at the 24/7 gym The plaza has it all.
Great pizza and wonderful service. It is quaint and has a space to host a small party, which is what we attended to get introduced to this place. We'll be back!
