Pink Pony - Bar & grill in Mackinac Island - 7221 Main St #103, USA

I went here right after I got off the boat. No waiting to sit even though it was very busy. Service was excellent, the waitress kept checking up even before our food arrived. I had the patty melt on marble rye bread. Wonderful my wife had the fish sandwich with the homemade chips. Excellent. Definitely a must go

Loved the atmosphere! Absolutely going to try it again. We got the white fish dip appetizer and Thai crunchy salad. The dip was really good. The salad was not. It tasted pineapply like. Service was terrible but I think he didn't like us waiting on the appetizer to order. Like I said, well try this again hoping it is better because I love the atmosphere!

Great atmosphere! Very fun and comfortable. Food was okay. We got a French dip and a burger. Service was horrible. Never got a refill, finished all of our food and never was asked how it was, had to ask for the bill and a to go drink because I paid $4 and never got a refill of my coke.

Amaaaaaaazing!!! We had the best meals of our 3 day wedding anniversary stay on Mackinac here (twice)! I had the celebration burger (medium) and it was the best burger I’ve had in years! Perfectly done with a fresh crispy onion ring in the middle with a sweet and sour (habanero sauce on it?) also the sweet potato fries were so good and unusual they had cinnamon sugar on them?! My husband had the fish and chips (twice!) since we came back on our final night as well. I had the rum runner since it was our cocktail at our wedding and this was just as good as a frozen blended version. We also got upper deck patio seeking right on the water (twice!). Short wait time for Thursday and Saturday at sunset under 20 min! And I gotta say for the best food on the island it’s also the most reasonably priced somehow?! We know we lucked out here and we plan to come back again next year and will definitely make it our tradition 💗🐴

The food was wonderful and so was the view! We sat outside and there was a heater so we were able to enjoy the view while staying cozy. Featured is the Pink Pony Punch and the Half Sandwich and Soup Combo of Turkey Sandwich and Tomato Soup!

Absolutely the #1 reason I will return to the island! This was my first trip to the UP and my first trip to the island and I was not disappointed to make the Pink Pony our first stop when we got off of the boat. I was recently recommended this place for a great Bloody Mary, little did I know I was getting more than a great drink. Our bartender Hannah was absolutely amazing from the time we sat down. The atmosphere was lively and Hannah’s presence and knowledge made our trip so much fun. We appreciate the service we received and felt like we were at home.

The food tastes amazing! It's definitely my favorite place to eat on Mackinac Island. The staff are very friendly. It is also a great place to eat if you have a gluten sensitivity or celiac... many options

We decided to eat at the pink pony on our day exploring Mackinac Island. The food was alright. Service was great! We got the pretzel sticks for an appetizer and those were phenomenal (try their homemade mustard!!) I got the turkey club sandwich and it was sadly a miss. Way too overpriced for a basic sandwich with burnt chips on the side. It would be cool if they put their own spin on it. Their famous drink (rum runner) was very delicious, but not quite worth the $16. Definitely a cute restaurant and good vibes, but don’t think we will be back.