Peppinos Italian Eatery - Restaurant in Williamson - 3734 NY 104, USA

Awesome. Stopped in this week for the meatball sub, my husband had the Marina Sauce with spaghetti. The homemade bread was hot out of the oven with seasoned whipped butter on the side. The home made dressings were fabulous ( Peppercorn, Ranch). The food was served hot and delicious. Prices were super good for lunch. Will be back.

Was in the mood for Italian and decided to try Peppinos Italian eatery. We were not disappointed. We tried the pasta with Sunday sauce with meatballs and sausage. The Sunday sauce was very flavourful. Also tried the chicken parm it was very good. Portions are huge. Enjoyed the next day leftovers. Cheese bread was not very flavourful but the mini loaf of bread with garlic butter was very good.

Was super excited to try Peppinos for the first time after hearing the hype . As I walked in the customer service was great and my food was ready 5 minutes early. I drove 35 minutes home to open our food to see “something“ on the top of my entre. My boyfriend & I ordered the same exact meal & his did not have what I had on top of mine. Same dish but no consistency.

Great Italian dishes. The red sauce is pork based with just the right amount of garlic and spices. The Alfredo and Blush sauce are both great. The pasta is cooked perfectly. The tripe appetizer is excellent. Good portions and decent prices. The food quality is surprisingly good for a small unremarkable location.

Even though this doesn’t look like 5 star experience on the inside the food is an easy 5 star. Simple and excellent menus selection. Incredible portion sizes. Food was incredible and the free garlic butter and fresh bread was phenomenal. The kids menu is a great price and also massive. My 10 year old was stuffed which rarely ever happens. Will definitely return!

The best Italian I've had in years. Everything is fresh and homemade with tons of options. Even the bread was made in house. The service is top notch and the prices are very good.

All you would ever expect for authentic Italian cuisine! Our waitress was working by herself, and did a fantastic job of taking care of all of her patrons! Will be back! :-)

Nothing against this place on the atmosphere, it is what it is. It actually lends itself to being quite a nice surprise. I dined there with two other people and everyone enjoyed everything they had. It's a very small, casual looking place, but the menu is extensive and the dishes are executed well. Our server was very attentive.