Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli - Deli in West Allis - 6125 W Greenfield Ave, USA

This place was AWESOME and Delicious!!! Will definitely return. Brought back many memories. Wide Variety of Jellies and Jams. We had samples of our products. Would be great for a date!!!

I picked up lunch for me and mom and the ladies at the counter were so friendly and helpful! The sandwiches were super good too. I wasn’t sure what I wanted and was recommended the grilled cheese with raspberry and jalepeno jelly- it was so yummy. We will come back soon!

Go there - you won't be disappointed. I've been there many times, and each experience was very positive. The sandwiches and soups are delicious! If you want a hardy, legitimate sandwich... this is the place to go! The workers are friendly and have a sense of humor. The menu has a ton of options, and you're able to customize your sandwich if you want to add or substitute something (adding bacon to anything makes it even more awesome).

I love peanut butter jelly deli! It’s so cute and I enjoy supporting local shops. My wife found their booth at an event a year or so back and we’ve been going there since. It’s close to home and a great place to get a delicious sandwich! I don’t know what magic they put it in but I can never get it the same at home. I also buy an inordinate amount of the honey roasted peanut butter from here…literal crack butter.

Really unique cafe in west allis. If you love ppjs, you'll love it here. Got the, you're killing me smalls, and it tasted like a ppj smore perfection. They got their own branded soda collection that has hints of ppj in it. Didn't try the coffee but they got deals for $1 coffee. They also have various jams for sale you can buy and take home. If you want to try something different in the Milwaukee area, come support this small local business.

I came in 30mins before closing and was greeted by all the staff with hello’s/hi’s/welcome. The lady that took my order was very sweet! I ordered the Strawberry Lovers and it was absolutely amazing!!! Definitely recommend and will be back very soon!!

Very fun joint if you love peanut butter and/or jelly. I got a grilled cheese with jelly (sharp cheddar and raspberry jalapeño) and it was dope af. Part of me regrets not getting the apple jelly but that's a decision I'll just have to live with for the rest of my life. There was a lot to look at while I waited for my sandwich so I did not get bored at all. My only critique would be to make a more cohesive merch area...it was kind of all over. That's minor though so I won't ding them for it. Great overall. I would recommend to anyone in the mood for a sweet sandwich.

A while back, Andrea Dexter and I stopped back in to Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli to try out their home-made PB&Js for lunch! What did we think? Let us tell you! First, let me say that Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli has an endless supply of home made jellys, jams, spreads, butters, etc. for you to try, mix and match on your sandwiches, and/or take home. Building a PB&J here comes with a wealth of options. We didn't go that route, rather opting for some of the pre-designed options, so we'll cover that here. Andrea Dexter had the Strawberry Lover's PB&J, which had fresh strawberries, crunchy honey roasted peanut butter, and a layer of strawberry jam on white toasted bread. The real game changer here is the fresh strawberries. The honey roasted peanut butter, also made in house and their best selling "butter", is delicious and creamy with full chunks of peanuts, and combined with the fresh strawberries creates a unique play on the classic PB&J. I, being the glutton that I am, opted for the "Double Decker", which I built with Seedless Raspberry Rhubarb Jam and All Natural Peanut Butter. Nothing special here, but the raspberry rhubarb jam was great, and i may have decided to switch to natural home-made peanut butter in the future because of this sandwich. Worth a stop in to see the full selection of options and take some jarred PB&J home with you. While you there, grab some lunch! You wont be disappointed. Parking isn't great (street parking only) so plan accordingly.