Pauls Live from New York Pizza Fortuna - Pizza restaurant in Fortuna - 101 12th St, USA

Excellent food, excellent service. It echos a lot and there are several TVs on loud, if you're sensitive to sound (I am). I will come back again. The prices are fair for the portions.

Pleasantly surprised. The food was great 👌. The service stood in the best ways possible. Super clean and cool facility. The wings are great. I recommend trying them!

I ordered Chicken Club pizza with their gluten free crust because the person that took my order over the phone said that most customers ordered their gluten free crust more than the cauliflower crust. It was very good. It was take out and my son picked it up. I can say that the service that I received over the phone was great and my son didn't complain about anything when he got home so the service there must have been okay. I can't speak to the atmosphere because it was take out. I did think that the price was a little high for the tiny little pizza that I got.

Really good pizza, they are still getting dialed in at this location but their pizza is good and the service is pretty good as well. They definitely get torrents of orders at times and they can take a while to get caught up. The dining area seems pretty nice but I’ve only ever order to go with their massive pizzas.

“Don’t Get Burned” Consistent Pizza? I think not! This is what we got for $60.00. As the last three times we ordered pizza from Paul’s it’s been burnt, as this time it is was EVEN worse. Whats even more bother some is we are 25 mins way, only to get home to find this monstrosity, Again…. What’s even more difficult to stomach is the taste of burnt pizza; something I found root beer cannot wash away! So, shame on me for going back! I will NEVER go back to Paul’s EVER again!! FYI… my dog even turned it down, but the trash didn’t deny it! 🤮

Sadly, the pizza crust has changed, and the pizza is lacking ingredients. This pizza is no longer what I remember Paul's to be famous for, and it's definitely not on par with a typical NY pizza. Not worth the 52 dollars I payed for for a 14 inch pizza. Save your money and go to domino's.

Totally enjoyed Paul’s live. Second visit as good as the first. As you can tell nothing left from the Fried Ravioli and mozzarella sticks. The mussel’s marinara were amazing last time and Cindy loves the pizza. Amazing that we can just have a slice. Btw, best fries in town. Thanks for coming to Fortuna.

Very, but very great service. I accidentally ordered at their Eureka location and they were very nice about it when they told me. They actually still made my order even though it was past closing and even called their other location to explain. Calzone is 100/100 definitely recommend. Big portions