Paulie's Pizza of Schenectady - Pizza restaurant in Schenectady - 409 Rosa Rd, USA

My family enjoys the consistent quality of the food at Paulie's Pizza. Everything we have tried so far tastes great! We really enjoy their pizza, subs, and wings and will continue to come back.

The pizza at Paulie’s is always perfect and one of the best in the area. I prefer the thin crust but their square pizza is excellent as well. Boneless wings are always great and their sauces are high quality and tasty. Eggplant parm was incredible. I’ve never had anything bad from their menu and their customer service is also top notch and friendly every time.

They aren't the worst pizza I've had, but their pizza is definitely inconsistent. I only come here because its around the corner from my house. I've had it too soggy or the sauce being too sweet, or just lack luster in general. Also it is quite irritating that when you order online it says a time it will be ready by, then I head to the shop and they tell me its going to be an additional 15 minutes because their times on the website are wrong, (just for a small cheese pizza btw). Can you fix that please?

Three and a half stars truly. A solid local pizza joint. Tried a slice fresh from the oven and an Italian mix sub. The bread was warm and tasty, the meats and cheese were good quality. The slice was pretty good, nothing to write home about but solid. The cheese and sauce eclipsed the dough. Weak crust. Fast and friendly service. Place was pretty clean looking. Give it a try!

Found out about it through a family member had delivery first time and takeout 2nd time both times it was exceptional 3rd time was takeout but the subs I ordered were not as good as before I'm sure it was something minor as the the young man was very cheerful and pleasant I still would recommend the place despite the glitch

Brought my granddaughter here for dinner on our special night out. She ordered a six-cut cheese pizza and I got a six-cut white GF pizza. She absolutely loved her pizza! Mine was okay. It is difficult to find a really good GF crust. This one was very thin and a bit; overcooked. I would recommend asking them to watch the crust carefully to avoid overcooking.

Ordered a 6 cut cheese pizza it was absolutely disgusting. The worst pizza I’ve even had in my life. So disappointing

I stopped in on a Sunday at 4 PM, in need of some serious calories, not too picky after burning off 3800 calories, and grabbed a couple of slices. I prefer to support local businesses when they exist. This place is one of those well-kept secrets that more people need to discover. As far as I could tell, the dough was made from scratch. It was more thin crust, but it was light and soft, not overworked, and had lots of texture to it. Cooked just right. Toppings were there, enough of them. But the star of the show was the sauce. I don’t know if it was homebrew or something off the foodservice truck, but that doesn’t matter. It had enough garlic to make it pop, but not so much to make it tart. Good quality tomato base, not over-oiled and didn’t taste like citric acid. I will go back to try their other offerings. It’s obvious they know what they’re doing and take enough care to get it right.