Pasta Cottage - Italian restaurant in Pueblo - 1525 E Evans Ave, USA

Can't go wrong with the handmade. My only issue is that I wish they had portion size options, just because I can probably eat darn near two of the handmade with meatballs orders happily but ordering 2 for one person is upwards of about 20 bucks just for entree. Well worth it but just hard to spend that much on takeout

1st time eating here and wasn't sure what to expect but it was good. The portions were good size...the Saturday special was spahgetti/and 2 meatballs with a roll and we also got a salad and it fed 2 people...the dressing was good and had blue cheese crumble. The staff working were super kind and friendly. We will definitely go back to try more. It's only take out also.

As an octogenarian (in my eighties) myself, I have found some great food in unexpected places. A friend heard me complaining that there were just no great Italian food places here in Pueblo CO. He asked if I had ever tried Pasta Cottage. I hadn't, so I tried it today and have now gladly eaten my words. The home made style spaghetti and meatballs meal is superb but the meatball sandwich was a small disappointment because of the two little rolls used with inadequate sauce. But I will be back again to try other things offered.

Overall this mom and pop shop fit the bill. The portions were plenty and price was decent. We ordered 2 orders of the stuffed shells and added a side of sausage. The two meals came with 5 rolls which was more than necessarry but appreciated. The salad we ordered was freshly made and tasted as good as it looked. My only complaint was that the pasta sauce was too sweet for my or my wife’s liking. It wasn’t bad but just too much sugar was used to cut the acid. I do think the sauce was home made. The menu included is updated as of 4/24/21 and is different than was posted 11 months ago.

Uuuuugh! Has always been so good since I was a kid. The fried chicken, spaghetti with meatballs and fresh salad is always the best. My one bugaboo would be the dinner rolls. They're hit or miss. I love them when they're fresh and soft. But, half the time they come dry and crumbly. But, that's seriously the smallest of issues...That and wish they had more convenient hours. However, everything else here is just delicious. Happy it's stayed in business and not changed for so long.

I have been going to Pasta Cottage as long as I can remember. They catered my two of my mother's birthday party's. As well as my nieces dinner after her funeral. The fried chicken is always great,the the pasta 🍝 and the dinner salads are fantastic. If you haven't had a chance to eat there cuisine you don't know what you're missing. Customer service is always great. I recently broke my leg and was unable to go in and get my orders. They brought it out to me with a smile and a thank you. Pueblo has a real 5 star ⭐ facility in the Pasta Cottage. Try it once and you won't go anywhere else. Best wishes for future success.

An absolute pueblo institution if you live here and have not eaten here stop what you are doing and try it out immediately. And if you are passing through definitely put this on your list unfortunately there is not much indoor seating but that is an excellent reason to order and head to city park for a outdoor experience and complete the experience.

Prices are to high two people $36 At least Colletti’s prices are reasonable