Park Street Pizza - Pizza restaurant in Sugarcreek - 215 R, Dover Rd NW, USA

Primo pepperoni pizza with vegan cheese (lactose intolerant) was a really great option! Everything was good, but I probably wouldn't consider the wings or fries to be worth the price. Staff was so friendly, though, and everything was well maintained and cleaned. Very pleasant experience!

This place was so amazing! We came here cuz it was one of the only places open on Sunday. And it did not disappoint!! Everything was amazing! If you are in town definitely try it ! We got buffalo boneless wing and BBQ bone in wings . And the modern Margherita pizza. And let me tell you this is prob in my top 3 all time favorite pizzas I have ever had !!! Definitely will come here again when in the area.

The first time here won't be the last. Has got to be the best pizza 🍕 around. I wish we had one near us. Friendly staff and clean inside. Had the Primo Pepperoni, outstanding, and also the boneless wings in smokey mustard were very good and plentiful. I can't wait to come back on our next visit.

The pizza here is very good. The staff is extremely pleasant and helpful. The dining area is roomy. I had the margarita pizza and a friend of mine. Let me taste his meatless tenders. Apparently they're made with mushrooms but they don't taste like mushrooms. They taste wonderful. I would never have ordered it not knowing but now that I do I will probably get them every time.

Great pizza! You may have to wait in line, but it will be worth it. The Rustic Chicken Pesto is an awesome pizza and Lucy is an awesome server! 10/10 want to do it again!

Very good pizza. The service was awesome! We had a cabin about 10min away that we had to drop cold food off at, they gave us an exact time the pizza would be ready. Called me at that time and it had just come out of the oven. Everyone was so nice and truly made the experience even for takeout amazing!

I’ve seen great posts on this in an Ohio roadtrip Facebook group, but never went because when in the area we wanted Amish food. This past Saturday, I went for lunch. Wow!! I got their signature pepperoni pizza and it was amazing! There was so much flavor in the pepperoni without being overbearing. The crust was perfect. My taste buds wanted to eat the whole thing then, but I wisely took the rest home. All the staff I encountered were friendly, helpful, and genuine. I will definitely go back.

Best Gluten Free pizza I've ever had, even better than my own which are pretty darn good. They have a lot of pizza options & I was able to chose any of their specialty pizzas or build my own on a GF crust! Their pizza has always been the best....even before I had to cut gluten from my diet. Park St. Pizza has been my long time favorite pizza & I'm so thrilled to be able to get a real size pizza with all my favorite toppings on GF crust! I had their Park St. Deluxe - it was excellent & plenty to box up & bring home. Fantastic staff & service is stellar. All around good people!