Oakley's Wood-Fired Pizza & Grill - American restaurant in Arkville - 44681 NY-28, USA

Ambiance (4/5): The inside is super cozy with low seating, dimly lit, and tight spaces. It feels like a rustic log cabin with a fireplace and a bar. The dining area overlooks the kitchen where the firewood oven is. There’s also outdoor dining as well as an enclosed outdoor dining area. The guests appeared to be mostly post-mountain skiers and families. Service (4/5): The establishment was very busy but there was plenty of staff members on the floor assisting. The workers were all very polite and quick to get us anything we needed. The pizza took 50 minutes so I’d recommend getting some appetizers to hold you over. Food (3/5): The bottom crust of the pizza was soggy so the bites were unsatisfying. The buffalo chicken pizza was delicious but ultimately, I’ve had much better pizza elsewhere. When reheating the pizza at home, we pan-fried them to allow for the bottom to get crispy and it was a drastically better slice.

Oakley’s is a great place for a warm bite to eat if you’re in the Catskills. The garlic knots were incredible — a slight crunch on the outside and perfectly doughy on the inside. Dunk ‘em in ranch! They were the highlight. The wood-fired pizza was good too. A bit floppy and cheesy but overall it was a good meal. Reasonably priced, too! This place is cozy, friendly, and has a good local feel to it.

Excellent experience. Mild chicken wings with garlic and sweet potato fries were delicious! Beer was cold. Staff was super friendly and attentive. Highly recommended. Coming from NJ, the service is much nicer!

Loved our dinner last night! We had garlic knots, “garbage” wings, and a large pepperoni and onion pizza. Garlic knots came out quickly and are sitting in a bowl of delicious garlic butter. It was hard not to finish them while waiting for the wings and pizza. I think we were accidentally given regular bbq wings, or the garbage wings just taste a lot like bbq wings. But I’m not complaining, they were huge wings and they were delicious! Just don’t expect them to taste like buffalo or garlic parm which is also supposed to be mixed in there. The pizza was also really good! They use red onions instead of yellow, which doesn’t bother me, but just wanted to note that. My only comment, which didn’t matter to my husband and I, but very clearly mattered to most of the other guests at the restaurant who looked displeased, was that service was very slow. I saw the servers apologize to three different tables for having to wait so long. It was a Thursday at 8:30pm which I’d think would be after the dinner rush. At least the servers are super friendly, and the food made up for the wait!

Lovely outdoor seating area - good room between tables. Food was delicious. Both the salad I had and the calzone my mother had were very tasty, and a large portion. Staff was very attentive and our server, Lili, was wonderful!

Delicious wood fired pizza! We had chicken bacon ranch pizza with Korean BBQ boneless wings. Everything was delicious & the staff was very friendly.

Every time I visit home I am sure to come to Oakley’s. The pizza is fantastic, the staff are always friendly and accommodating and if you’re lucky they’ll be live music. Indoor and outdoor seating. Cannot forget to mention their spectacularly clean bathrooms. If you’re ever in the neighborhood do yourself a favor and stop by Oakley’s.

Excellent stop for some amazing appetizers and pizza. The atmosphere is fantastic and the employees are super friendly and attentive. We ordered for appetizers, french fries, sweet potato fries, calamari, garlic shrimp, garlic knots, and fried pickles. Then we also got a margarita pizza and a white cheese pizza. You should definitely give this amazing place a try!