NYPD Pizza Lake Cay - Pizza restaurant in Orlando - 9900 Universal Blvd #100, USA

We got an 18 inch pepperoni pizza and a half order of garlic knots. Both are good and a good value for your money. Pizza has a nice ratio of sauce, cheese, and pepperoni for the most part, but on one half of the pizza the sauce had been overloaded and wasn't edible. Every other part of the pizza was great. Garlic knots are cheap and exceptionally tasty.

What a gem 💎 in Orlando! Always keep going back. The pizzas are top notch, better than many pizzas I’ve had in New York, as someone who’s from that area. Service is friendly and prices are really reasonable. The area is nice and quiet and family friendly. You can get a large pizza to share with 2-3 people for under twenty bucks. If you want a good pizza come here and avoid the cheaper chains, you won’t be disappointed!! My favorite is the queens deluxe pizza, the toppings make it delicious.

Was staying close by. Walked to this pizza place. Lady at the front was nice and told me where to order a (to go order). That lady was nice and helped me out. Ordered two single slices and some garlic knots. It wasn’t overly pricey and it tasted great. FYI the lady in the back handling all the orders really helps that place run smoothly. She made sure everyone got their order as soon as it came out of the oven.

Ordered Chicken Parm and Chicken Alfredo. Hubby advised against ordering pasta. We normally get pizza from this exact location and it’s always top tier! These two pasta dishes were absolutely dry! No sauce on the side at all. I’m an hour away and will not be driving back. But I also will not be driving back there for pasta.

Great place. We all enjoyed the pizza, salad, and wings. The service was also good. Our server was very sweet. The mango habanero wings were delicious. Prices were also pretty good for a resort area. Nice little bar area with plenty of different TVs playing. Lolly pops for the kids also. I also enjoyed to vegetarian pizza.

You will find delicious pizza and Italian cuisine here for a reasonable price. The ambiance is simple and perhaps a touch insulting to New York's finest, but the litigation that took place regarding the NYPD logo and name was finished around '05. Just keep in mind that if you are going to the place because you back the blue, you are being played. The judgment they received insisted that they must post a message that states they are not endorsed by or connected with the New York Police Department and that they cannot run their establishments in the domain of said organization. I am not saying that the logo and name aren't clever, but to some, they may seem a touch disingenuous and misleading. That said, I found that the Rustic Salsiccia pizza was a delight. The caramelized onions and garlic really stood out, and the sausage was wonderfully flavorful. They have done well at putting themselves squarely in the middle of the fresh ingredients pizza movement that has risen out of the dust of the old corporate model. The garlic knots were nice, but perhaps a little overdone. My mother's calzone, which was the pepperoni roll, was quite nice if the bite I sampled was any indication. Other members of my table enjoyed the meatball appetizer and the chicken club Pizza. Based on my experience, if only for the food, this is generally going to be a very good bet in the area of International Drive. Our service was wonderful. Our waitress, Hunter, took excellent care of our table and made sure everybody's cups were full, food was promptly distributed, and that everybody was satisfied with their meal. So, short of some personal qualms I have about the marketing strategy employed by this chain, I have to recommend that you consider them seriously if you are looking for New York style pizza in this region of Orlando's tourist corridor.

As delicious as the food was, it was the friendly and professional service that stood out. Our waitress was so kind and didn't rush us at all at closing time even though we offered to leave, so they could lock up behind us. We will be back and will be recommending this place to loved ones that visit Orlando.

Convenient location near the convention center, easy to get in and out with ample parking due to being in a shopping center. I had dine-in lunch on a weekday; the place was very busy but the staff was friendly and the service was still quick. I ordered a 10" pizza ("Queens Deluxe Pie") and the quality and quantity of toppings was perfect. Nice thin pepperoni, flavorful sausage, and the onions were not overpowering. Surprisingly not very greasy either. The crust has a great chewy texture while still maintaining a slightly crispy outside. My daughter had the lunch special which included a bowl of fettuccine Alfredo (half the dinner size) and a side salad. The side house salad had a fresh quarter tomato, thinly sliced red onion, croutons, and thick cucumber slices. The prices are great, especially if you order a pre-set specialty pizza versus adding a custom list of your own toppings. The New York theme is unique and unobtrusive. I did not visit the bar area but it looked cozy from afar. I'm really glad that we stopped here for lunch and would be happy to go back again the next time we're in the area looking for lunch or dinner.