NewCastle Comics & Games - Comic book store in Maryland Heights - 2294 McKelvey Rd, USA

First time in, looking for Magic singles, and it was a great time. They don't do Flip-thru binders but they have something better. Their Online Singles System was ready to use and me and a Staffer went one by one, looking at the stock they had, and were able to pull a ton of what I wanted in about a 1/4 of the time it would have taken with binders. You can also access this Online Feature right from your own computer/phone, AND they do same day order pick up with their singles. Just put everything you want into the cart and send it over to get pulled and picked, once you get there they should just about have it ready! ALSO they have a TON of stock form Magic, with Booster Boxes/Packs/Singles/and Commander Decks from all across the different Realms! Check them out! I WILL be going back, and bringing friends!

Daren and Dave made my first time in an amazing experience. They have a large selection of comics, and boardgames. Oh my God the boardgames! They told me about the best holiday "Free Comic book day" around May the 4th. I will most definitely be coming back, 10\10 service ☺️

Very friendly and knowledgeable staff. Wide variety of all things comic and tabletop-related. 5/5 stars :)

Went to NewCastle today for Free Comic Book Day. It remains my favorite comic book shop in the St Louis area. There's always something fun and nerdy playing on the TV in the store, and the store layout is very organized and easy to navigate. As bonuses, they have a decent selection of manga and quite a lot of board games available to purchase. The owner is incredibly nice and remembered what we talked about the last time I was there (even though it had been months since then!).

This comic book shop is amazing!! Such a great selection of new and back issues as well as tons of variant covers. Customer service is top notch as well! The owner is extremely knowledgeable and was so helpful when we were there and took the time to help us find what we needed. He even threw in a few free items! If you’re looking for an outstanding comic shop with the best customer service, look no further!

Decent selection of comics and novelties. The magic cards are not easy go through as just in boxes behind counter. Price for selling MTG cards is on the lower end and takes a little while to finish the deal. Decent selection of comics reasonable priced. Store has some cool toys but not the best to sell MTG to.

Very fun, lots of comics and role-playing games to check out.

This store has been in place for a few years but I just found it. I was very impressed by the volume of comics and games available. I could have spent hours looking through the collections. I highly recommend and will be back again and again.