New York Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza restaurant in Fern Park - 7800 S US Hwy 17 92, USA

Tried this place for the first time, and can honestly say it definitely honors its current 4.7/5 rating. It is the best pizza spot so far in the area strictly from a traditional cheese pizza slice comparison. We ordered both a Popeye and regular Cheese (dine-in) for an accurate review. The Popeye had a significant crisp on the bottom as well as a crunchy crust. The Cheese had a similar bottom crisp but not as much as the Popeye. I love the price of the cheese. The Popeye seemed a bit pricey compared to the flavor, I had to add more salt to each bite. Will definitely visit again to try other items but purely from a regular Cheese, this is the spot 🔥

Really awesome find. The food was awesome. Great NY style pizza. Glad we ordered a large pizza, plenty of leftovers for take home. And antipasto salad was delicious and fresh with oil and vinegar. As were the garlic rolls, loads of garlic and butter. So good, If you're on the fence, give them a try.

It was my first time and I ordered the Popeye and this was literally one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time and one of the best Ive ever had period. The garlic knots were good too!!

So we won lunch on the company for the store and we ordered two pies and 30 wings. I have to say the pizza was really on point. I'm from up north and it's hard to find good pizza shops in Florida that replicate the style and taste of new york pizza. This hit the mark. Will be one of my go to places for both wings and pizza, the hot wings were like a medium. Not too spicy and very tasty

I ate their for the first time today. The pizza has a crispy crust but to much cheese their was not a balance between the sauce and cheese, very little sauce. If they add more sauce to their pizza, I'll come back.

First time I've been there and OMG it was INCREDIBLE! I ordered a takeout order and it surpassed expectations. The pizza, *chefs kiss*. The wings, literally perfect. I will 10000000% order from here from now on. Do yourself a favor and don't make dinner tonight, order this pizza!

This review is based on a takeout order, we had a large pizza for the first time from this restaurant. The food was good, wasn't the best pizza that we've had locally but very close. That's why the four stars. Service was very good food was done in time, and I enjoyed my first experience.

The pizza is consistently amazing my hubby and used to try all the pizza places in Altamonte and we found heaven with there New York style 18' with ricotta cheese and pepperoni and I get a side of garlic aioli for dipping my crust and it's so amazing the ingredients they use are fresh I can tell. I'm from Chicago where we are picky about our pizza and this place is by far the best in town.