Montville Diner Restaurant - American restaurant in Pine Brook - 4 US-46, USA

My food was Fantastic, My server was Fantastic, My experience here was Fantastic! I had a Fantasic time!

The place is OK If you want something fast and are not too picky. The servers are really great. But the food is cheap quality and the place feels like it hasn't been updated since the 70s. Every time we go it's NEVER busy. I think they really need a signature dish that will make people go there for.

I got the an omelette and it was very delicious. The server was a ginger woman(I didn’t get the name). She was very nice and was often checking up on us seeing how the food was. She food was all very good. And I had a great time dining here!

I hadn’t seen my parents in 3 years, and I met them for brunch at this location. I ordered an orange juice and they brought me Tang juice without telling me. I wouldn’t have minded so much if they had just said “sorry we don’t have that -would you like Tang” My mom ordered coffee and it came in a dirty cup with grass on the rim. The fries tasted good but were extremely oily. The omelet was inedible, and completely dry. My brother who loves food took one bite from his wrap and put it down. Do not recommend

Nice local diner, food was good, plenty of parking. Staff is friendly!

Service and Food was great! Highly recommended and appreciated everything.

12/9/23 - had a sit down brunch. Ordered Mac n cheese, fruit salad, vegetable omelette, side of bacon, pastrami Reuben. Mac n cheese was so saucy you couldn’t anything but cheese and sauce. Bacon had a synthetic taste. Reuben had 80% cheese and sauerkraut, 20% meat. Coffee tasted old and stale. Went to cash out, told the lady cashing, and the owner nearby. Was still charged full price ($51.00). Could’ve argued for the discount, but was eager to get on with my day. Food was really bad. On top of all that, they did not offer to discount my meal which was much more infuriating.

Always great tasting food and good service. Staff is friendly and helpful. Nice atmosphere inside! Great omlettes and waffles!!