Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza - Italian restaurant in Morristown - 60 South St, USA

This place is absolute Magic! I had not one but two types of meatballs, did you know meatballs could come in vodka sauce? Well, they are now officially my new favorite thing ! Everything here is scratch made with love you can tell in the taste of the pizza ! Even the salads are like a work of art.

I brought my son and his friends to the pizza making class at Millie's. It's a private class (either an 11:30 or 3:30 time slot) for a minimum of 6 people, and you get a whole room in the back to yourselves. The teacher demonstrated how to handle and knead the dough. We then brought our dough to the cooking area where the teacher talked about the brick oven, and we added the sauce and had a huge selection of toppings. The pizza cooked in 90 seconds in the brick oven. We had such a fun time!!

(Byob) Great experience while eating here! Everything is delicious here. Their meatballs are to die for! And their coal fired pizza was cooked to perfection - Nothing compares to their crust. We had the crustini and their candied bacon and walnut salad with crumbled blue cheese. We ordered a margerhita pizza and chicken parm as main dishes. For dessert we had Oreo cake and chocolate mousse cake with espresso and a cappuccino. Yum! 😋

I came here for the first time and I had such a great experience dining here! My server was Santiago and he was great! He helped me pick out what I wanted and did an amazing job! I got the pesto ricotta pie and fresh mozzarella caprese. So good! Will come again.

I liked the pizza very much. The atmosphere was pleasant, and the service was good. However, I would like to mention that the crust was slightly burnt. It would have been better if it had been more evenly cooked. Although my friend’s pizza was ok so I would say this was just an accident. Overall, recommend this place.

$12 for two average meatballs. The presentation is nice but the taste is pretty standard unfortunately. Pictured is the meatballs with vodka sauce. Too expensive for what it is. Pizza is good, I would recommend that over the meatballs. I would recommend just sharing the smaller pie. It's enough for two people even though there's only four slices. Long waits and usually always busy which leads to poor service because there isn't enough staff working the floor. Be prepared to make your drink last throughout the meal - no one will check on you if it's busy.

It is one of the best places for pizza. We ordered the oysters, and it was awesome, but it was pricey. The pizza was really good. It's a good spot for dining.

Go here for the best meatballs ever served in a very tasty marinara sauce. Take a pass on the doughy undercooked "coal fired" pizza. Dine outside or order take-out to avoid the sticky tables and horrible disinfectant odor that permeates the dining room.