Mamma Mia! Cafe & Pizzeria - Pizza restaurant in New Windsor - 318 Blooming Grove Turnpike, USA

This restaurant has the friendliest most caring owners and outstanding service! The food never fails to amaze me, my family and I eat here at least once a week and have never been disappointed! The pizza is definitely the best pizza around this area and the entrees are always cooked to perfection! I would definitely recommend trying this food whether you dine in, take out or have it delivered for breakfast, lunch or dinner. They truly do it all here!

I’ve been to this place many times and I’ve never been disappointed! I ordered a personal trio stromboli and it must’ve been the best I’ve ever had! It was very well cooked and goes really well with the marinara sauce. The burgers are also very tasty, such as the tavern and the Windsor burger and even the bacon cheeseburger (the nutty hog if you are brave enough). The meat is just how I like it and fills me up real quick! Overall, my experience at this place is extremely well and I’d definitely recommend mamma Mia cafe for anyone who ever has the munchies.

* UPDATE.. SUB N FRIES FRIES , FRIES ! 😍City Replant... NO greasy, thick, gooey crust!Gr8 Pizza! , Try the Corn Ribs, for Sure, BreakFast All Day! This is the Spot.... The End.

Excellent food and service! Generous portions. I recommend the pizza with meatballs and sweet potato fries, but others with me ordered fish and chips, salad, and chicken cutlet parmesan, all of which were cooked and seasoned perfectly. Definitely recommend!

This business never disappoints! I've eaten from them on a couple different occasions. They have Delicious food and great customer service. I will be going there again.

Another great get-together at Mamma Mia's. We enjoyed the chicken parm, shrimp scampi , chicken lemon, and eggplant. The carrot cake and the mouth-watering lemon rasberry drop were absolutely delicious. The food tonight was absolutely top quality, and the service was fantastic. Thanks to the crew at Mamma Mia's for another great dining experience !!!

I called and asked if there were onions in vodka sauce they assured me there were not. I ordered on grub hub and also wrote no onions in vodka sauce in instructions. Guess what? There were onions in the sauce. Never again will I order from here. In response to your response below. I heard your employee ask someone if there were onions in the sauce and they said no. It was wrong of you to repremand your new employee. Also I looked back at my grub hub order and it said "no onions in the sauce"

1st time visit. Bought a couple subs (Turkey, American combo) here and a wrap(chippy chicado) for takeout. Everything was great and they don't use cheap deli meats like other places. Definitely will return.