Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery, 374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553, United States
Geo Location
Lat long (41.4599934,-74.0552773)
Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery - Featured Reviews (269)
We’ve been coming here for years and the food is great. Service too. But lately they have been using an aerosol. Window cleaner to wipe the table’s down and it travels across the small room and gets in the way of the great tasting food. A pump spray bottle Is the proper tool for the job. Hope someone reads this as I don’t like to complain. :-(
I didn't realize lasagna construction consisted of 5 layers of straight pasta sheets. Your $17 is better spent elsewhere. In the past, my chicken parm has been pounded so thin that I was basically eating bread. I'm about done with this place. Gets one more star for the flavor and that's about it.
Great experience, Had Prusetta Bread wow good, then Shrimp Scampi and Eggplant Parmigiana. Everything was cooked to perfection and delicious, we will definitely be back!
You can never go wrong ordering dinners or pizza from this yummy place. Though portions have shrunk slightly, the chicken parm and eggplant rollatini with penne vodka are scrumptious and reasonably priced . They have the best homemade pizza rolls and delicious salad, too. I have catered many events from here. I would also rather order from here for Christmas Eve dinner than make dinner myself. Love their sauce. Love their pizza, too. Great hot wings, too. If you are looking for awesome hot or cold sandwiches, then look no further. Momma T's Italian and Vailsgate bravest or finest are very yummy, too. My son loves their meatballs and won't eat mine. Lol! Take out or eat in. They have delivery too.
We enjoyed our tasty meal of penne ala vodka with grilled chicken and shrimp. I will definitely order it again!
Food is great. Pizza is great atmosphere is great. The service is ok . Messed up my order one time and gave my pizza to someone else. Other than that I can’t complain.
As a service member, I travel all over, but I recently got back into town, and it is good to know that after so many years, this place continues to serve great quality food and excellent customer service. I always get their margarita pizza and rice balls.
The pizza and food are always cooked perfectly.....and the customer service is always cool.
Frequently asked questions About Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery
Where is Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Located ?
Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Located in New Windsor of 374 Windsor Hwy. The complete address is Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery, 374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553, United States.
Can I get the contact No of 'Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery' ?
Yes you can contact over this +1 845-561-6262 no.
Is there any website for 'Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery' ?
This restaurant has the friendliest most caring owners and outstanding service! The food never fails to amaze me, my family and I eat here at least once a week and have never been disappointed! The pizza is definitely the best pizza around this area
We asked for a cup of their marinara sauce before we ordered There sauce is not sweet thank god! I find a lot of pizza places make their sauce sweet like candy. I donât know why . Itâs Small place but there pizza is excellent.
I love coming here. There are so many beautiful and informative displays. They also change a few displays occasionally, so it makes each visit a new experience. I am a recipient of the Purple Heart, wounded in Iraq. I feel greatly honored that a pl
El Jalepeno Charro is THE BEST restaurant in New Windsor. The family is wonderful, personable, friendly - they treat you like family! The atmosphere is fun and lively! Anything on the menu is delicious! Brunch is fantastic and what we came for today!
Owner waited on us, actually the whole bar! Great service, excellent Guinness, wings, soup, and amazing homemade blue cheese dressing! We will be back. :)
We were here 17 years ago and decided to come here to have a Romantic Picnic here to celebrate our 7th wedding anniversary â¤ï¸ ð ð it was wonderful the view as we sat on the bench eatig home made Buffalo chicken wings, watermelon, olives
You can smell the herbs and spices of Trinidad soon as you walk through the door. Very nice people who greet you soon as you come in. Food was fresh and hot. Curry chicken Roti was excellent. Buss up was nice and fluffy. Prices are a little bit on th
Nice variety of Hot Food ready to go as well as menu items. Service was prompt and courteous. Food was fresh and delicious. Nice portions for the price.
