Lizzie Keays Restaurant - Restaurant in Warrensburg - 89 River St, USA

Overpriced and fake upscale. The margarita drink (can't remember the exact name) tasted watered down. Crab stuffed mushrooms were disappointing. They tasted good... But were swimming in a pool of broth that tasted like ramen noodles and we had shells in our stuffing. Chicken Parm was sitting in a mess of watery sauce and overcooked noodles. Mashed potatoes were watery with no flavor, almost wondered if they were previously frozen. Pork loin was overcooked and dry. Wait staff was nice, but wasn't spectacular Good place to take your grandparents since they like things undersalted and overcooked.

This place should have been super busy on a Saturday night, as the food was fantastic, the waitress was wonderful and the atmosphere was nice and cozy. It was a perfect double date night dinner for the 4 of us.

Great place but our waitress seemed very inexperienced. Service was slow but otherwise we had a lovely dinner. I know restaurants have generally had difficulty getting staff so I just chalked it up to that. Still, new staff should probably be a bit more monitored and assisted as needed. It's certainly on our list of places we'd be happy to go again.

Lizzie Keays is the perfect intimate wedding venue. Words cannot express the love and gratitude we have for Jeff and Jess at Lizzie Keays. When we asked them to host our reception, they were so accommodating and affordable, and even allowed us to come in 48 hours in advance to decorate for the wedding day. As for the food — Lizzie Keays offered the option for signature cocktails, and open bar. They created a mouthwatering cocktail hour menu of Buffalo chicken egg rolls (a favorite of Nick’s no longer on the menu) stuffed mushrooms, crudites, a cheese platter, and Jess even suggested the option for a Lemonade Bar which was an absolute hit with the kids! Dinner was served quickly and efficiently. Every guest chose between 5 dinner options except for the kids who could choose their meals a la carte ( another great idea of Jess’s) I am still dreaming about the feta and spinach stuffed salmon and Nick loved the prime rib with garlic mashed potatoes. Simply put, Lizzie Keays is an absolute hidden gem in Warrensburg. I encourage anyone looking for an intimate venue to choose them for your reception. Jeff and Jess — you are family to us now, expect to see us often and speak your praises for life!!

First time staying in Warrensburg and decided to give something local a try. Glad we did not pay attention to the one bad review I saw. The restaurant itself is a quaint little place with nice decor. Our waitress seemed newer, but Tatiana was very helpful and was moving around at top speed. She did a wonderful job serving us. Then comes the food. One word comes to mind, “Terrific” There were 4 of us and everything came out spot on and the meals were fairly priced and the portions were more than enough! We definitely will return next time we are in the area!

The service was great, and the food was delicious - but please make sure your staff understands what “gluten free” means. Only two items on the menu had a “GF” marking, one appetizer, and one entree. That’s not a whole lot of choice for someone with a gluten allergy in 2023, so we asked about the ingredients in other menu options, hoping there might be more choice, and there was confusion. At one point we were told that the mashed potatoes weren’t gluten free because they contained butter… Please make sure you know what gluten free means!

Was camping in the area and given reviews we were looking forward to good meal for our sons birthday. Unfortunately, we were completely dissatisfied. High price for a low quality meal. Waited over an hour for our meal. Burned the kids chicken nuggets and then only brought one order out that were rubbery. My husbands scallops were cold and lacked flavor. Salad dressings were watered down and also lacking flavor. Completely disappointing and wouldn’t recommend.

Absolutely the most amazing meal my family has had in a long time. The prime rib was top notch as was everything we ordered. I would say this is by far the hidden gem of restaurants in Warrensburg.