Island Lake Diner - Diner in Ronkonkoma - 625 Portion Rd, USA

Exceptional Dining Experience at Island Lake Diner! From the moment we stepped into the Island Lake Diner, we knew we were in for a treat. The warm, welcoming atmosphere set the perfect tone for a delightful meal. The staff greeted us with genuine smiles and attended to our every need with efficiency and care. The menu is a wonderful blend of classic and innovative choices, catering to a wide range of tastes. What truly stood out was the diner’s commitment to quality. Every ingredient tasted fresh, and the attention to detail in both cooking and presentation was evident. The portions were generous, satisfying our appetites completely. To top it all off, the pricing was reasonable for the quality and quantity of food served. It’s a place where you get more than what you pay for. In conclusion, Island Lake Diner is a hidden gem. We left with a happy heart and a promise to return soon. For anyone looking for a high-quality dining experience with a personal touch, this is the place to go. Five stars well-deserved!

This is not just an average diner. The service was excellent and friendly,the meals were cooked to perfection and served in an expeditious fashion. There's an obvious reason why they have been in business since I was a child and now bring my child there. Generationally great.

Love this diner! The staff take care of you and the l owner always comes around and makes sure you’re having a good experience. Food is good and the portions are large and always fresh. They always give my 4 year old a free cookie on our way out. Very sweet!

It's crucial for restaurants to accurately fulfill orders as advertised on their menu. Blaming drivers for missing items when the bag arrives stapled shows an internal flaw in the to-go order preparation. As someone with previous managerial experience in food service, I understand the importance of rectifying such service issues promptly. I urge the restaurant to either update their menu accurately or ensure precise order fulfillment. The consistent errors make it challenging for me to continue ordering from them, considering the repeated mistakes. It's imperative to educate staff on proper to-go order preparations to provide better service and fulfill customer expectations.

This was a great experience. We came to this diner a little over two years ago. My wife and I wanted to relive the experience. We are visiting from Florida. The food was excellent. The service was excellent. The atmosphere is friendly and full of love. I recommend this diner.

Sad to leave one star. I've been a loyal weekly customer for over 3 years. On a recent visit, my son ordered 2 chicken breasts with rice and vegetables. Half way through, we noticed the chicken was red inside. Although apologetic, my son who opted to take a cheeseburger home at that point as he lost his appetite. When we received the bill, they charged us for the burger. In my opinion, and in good business, his meal at the very least should have been comped. This is unacceptable especially to loyal customers. Sadly, we will not return

I usually have a great experience when dining in at this diner, but recently left extremely disappointed in online ordering. I had placed an order through their website link, and after driving all the way to the restaurant, pull into the lot and receive a text, my order is canceled. No big deal I go in and order the same food to go. The bill came to $25 more than the order I placed on their website. I feel robbed, that is too much off a price difference for them to still have online order links available.

I went for dinner tonight and it wasnt that good at all. They were very busy which was to be expected so I know the cooks were hurrying to get the food out. The food wasn’t cooked well enough. they forgot my Cole slaw and pickle on my cheeseburger deluxe, and the burger was more on the raw side when I asked for medium. my son got mozzarella sticks that weren’t cooked enough. I didn’t say anything because I didn’t wanna make a scene and I was in a hurry to get out of there because I had someplace to go. When I was paying the check, they’re watching me to see what tip I put down and then the younger guy with black hair and black beard actually said it out loud. It was my first time there and I won’t be going back.