Idaho Pizza Company - Pizza restaurant in Caldwell - 4816 Cleveland Blvd, USA

Decent restaurant. The staff are friendly, the food is good. I have preferences of other pizza places, but here they have a well stocked salad bar, many different varieties of sauces and a build your own option. The restaurant is clean, and often quiet.

I came for lunch to enjoy the all you can eat buffet. I enjoyed my salad first but noticed the spinach and lettuce was wilted in most areas. I went to try the variety of pizzas next. There was ham + pineapple, pepperoni, supreme, all cheese, and Buffalo chicken + jalapenos. I thought there would be more options. I physically can't eat pork. I love spicy chicken. I grabbed two cheese pizzas and a buffalo chicken. The cheese pizza tasted sweet and I did not like it. I went to go get more buffalo chicken and that seemed to be the number one seller because it was gone fast. Still having a good hour for all you can eat, I asked the front of house if the cook would be making more buffalo pizza. They were polite enough and provided the right expectations that it is the cook's decision so no promises but they will ask. After some time another employee came by my table asking if everything was ok. I informed them I could only eat the buffet pizza and only had one slice, so I was waiting for the buffalo pizza. She said she would check. 20 minutes later a supreme pizza and a sausage pizza came out. They stopped checking on me and all hid in the back. I waited 10 more minutes and kept checking the pizza bar but no new pizzas came out. I was very sad because that was the only Pizza I could have eat and I only got one slice. A salad, a drink and one slice of pizza was not worth the price I paid. The salad bar was very dirty. The atmosphere was very hot due to fire. I didn't think it was kid friendly. I paid to sit and wait. Not a very good experience. I was going to be meeting family but I told them it was not worth coming here. We went somewhere else.

Fantastic pizza. The service is alright and the atmosphere is okay at this location. Feels a little dated. But a local staple and the pizza keeps us coming back.

Great pizza. Fast service for pizza. I went inside and ordered. Took typical wait time for the order. Atmosphere is rustic. Would be a good place for a team party. Price averaged $23 per pizza for our 2 large pizzas (all meat and a hawaiian). It fed 7 adults and 2 kids, but would have been nice to have had a 3rd pizza for that many people.

I come here often and have had good experiences but today. I Dined in ordered 2 pizza and some bread sticks. One pizza and breadsticks came out but they never brought out our main Pizza. When I asked where it was they never made it. The manager I’m guessing gave me a refund never aplogized, they should have gave us a refund and a free pizza for making us wait for 45 min for nothing. Very frustrating.

We have been to two different Idaho Pizza. The one closest to Caldwell is where we prefer to go as it is much closer. Food was great but employee at counter was not as smiley and she could have been, maybe just a bad day!

Went to a baby shower here. There was a room reserved for the event. Very blah and lots of brown. Not sure if the service question is really relevant. Seeing how they didn't cater to us. They brought us 3 pizzas at the beginning. And then we didn't see them again until they kicked us out at 9pm lol the pizza was not what I have had there before. It was good, just not as good as it was before I have gone. Pizza dough was soft. It was really greasy much more then normal.

Update: Went there for a quick family dinner on a Wednesday evening. Not busy at all. Service was good. Salad bar could have been a little better. There were plenty of kids standing around that could have been cleaning/freshening up/refilling the salad bar area. The gluten free pizza and hot wings were good.