Frosty Frog, 503 N Washington St, Castalia, OH 44824, United States
Geo Location
Lat long (41.4043324,-82.810578)
Frosty Frog - Featured Reviews (249)
Great location I frequent the Frosty Frog when I'm in Castalia! I take my Grandson for shakes before driving thru Resthaven Squatchin! I can only contest to having Shakes & Sundaes which are fantastic and fair prices!
We visit the Frosty Frog every time we’re in the Sandusky area. It is a hole in the wall located in the small town of Castalia. Everything is on the menu and you can’t go wrong. Staff is always so friendly. Wait times can get long as they’re usually busy (being one of the only restaurants in the town) and everything is made fresh to order. We went twice a day on our last trip. Prices are more than reasonable. Other items that aren’t pictured we ordered were : walking tacos, pizza burger, taco fries, Hawaiian fruit slush, Mac and cheese bites, pepperoni rolls, and cheesy garlic toes.
Their selection is extensive with food and ice cream items. We had their small Flurry equivalent which was a good sized portion. The drive through line was crazy long but window service was fairly quick. Prices seemed in line with most competitors.
Love the food. The only complaint was being eaten alive by mosquitoes while waiting for food.
Sign shows 12-7. Closed at 650. Got a couple sad kids. Heck of a business model. And I don't want to hear staffing non sense, I could see two people there through the blinds. Thanks for nothing.
Expensive for getting almost no candy in my flurries. The top inch had candy the other four/five inches was plain ice cream. And no it wasn't just because it wasn't mixed enough cause if it was mixed there still wouldn't have had enough candy to even taste good. This place has gone down hill so bad. I'll just drive into sandusky to get ice cream from now on.
My wife and I stopped for lunch. We both had chili dogs and shared mozzarella sticks. The chili dogs were great, with homemade sauce. Will go back whenever we are in Castalia.
For $4.75 we got a small chocolate malt a medium twist cone. Cool refreshing treats. Great friendly service reasonable prices good selection sandwiches fried snacks dairy treats. Love convenience location too. Win win
