Five Points Cafe - Bar & grill in Sayville - 1 Main St, USA

We had lunch with a long lost relative today. We arrived around 12pm and were the only customers for at least 1/2 an hour. This worked out good for us since we had a lot of catching up to do. The food looked good and tasted fine. The waitresses were nice so overall it was a pleasant experience. It's just that nothing stood out that made it special. But give it a try.

Certain dishes are OK. Many are very bland. Ordered the steak sandwich made with "shaved prime beef" which turned out to be some kind of processed beef "like" meat product that was ckmpletely flavorless. I call it "like" because it was definitely processes meat recombined into something thar loosely resembled a cooked piece of deli sliced roast beef except it was completely uniform in texture unlike real meat. The service is always great. Never a complaint with these people. The kitchen will make something off the menu (the burgers are great but i prefer chicken breast instead) and no complaints from the kitchen staff. Need to be careful on nights with music as the musicians seem to have a difficult time understanding the venue is small and they need to leave the orchestra at home, especially the giant cymbols, kettle drums, and brass sections. Stick to the guitars guys, hell, even a flute or other softer woodwind instrument. Keep it light, people are trying to eat and converse. Which is the next topic. The place can get a little loud during the rush since it is small and they do fill up fast. Add a rude musician blasting a trumpet (I kid you not) inside a room about the size of a large livingroom amd youve got a walk out crowd or miserable dining experience.

Nice local, live music, good for a Friday (end of week) dinner. Cozy and friendly, staff are all nice. Bartender serves drinks in any old clean glass, weather a beer or not....so probably should order a beer! Recommend and will be back.

1st time I've eaten there and it was really good! There was a 30 minute wait at around 6:45 on a Saturday night so we sat at the bar. Selina, the bartender was attentive. Ordered the Cajun chicken sandwich with cheddar and a salad. The sandwich was very tasty and the sauce had a nice "kick." The kitchen staff kept just kept pumping out orders (to go & dine-in). There was live music too.

My husband and I eat here pretty regularly, and the food and service are always top-notch. We’ve tried many of their menu items, some of our favorites being the southwest salad, chipotle bbq chicken salad, the reuben, and the blt. Their monthly specials are always delicious as well! We love eating on their outdoor patio that is dog-friendly. The servers are always so sweet to our dog and bring her a water bowl every time. They also have live music on certain days. Great, casual restaurant to hang out and get a consistently good meal!

Great place for food and drinks. Tried many different items on the menu and all were great. Staff is super friendly and attentive.

We got seated promptly. Place has nice outdoor sitting area which was main reason we picked it. Some live music which ended 15 mins after we sat down. Server was pleasant although failed to check on us. Mosquitoes were biting us, they did have citronella candles but have not offered to turn them oil on for us. Food was nothing special. I had the cali and burger that cost 15 bucks. Had better burgers even chillis has better burgers. Kids food came was brought after we were done with our food. Why they would not serve us all at the same time? I had to feed my kid from my plate. It was only chicken tenders ans fries.

We were walking through town in January and it was blustery so my girlfriend suggested we step in to the 5 Point. It was worth the visit, we decided on Seared Ahi Tuna on mixed greens, and crab cakes with white wine house special while seated at the bar. Jessica, our bartender made sure everything was perfect so we were reluctant to go back out into the cold.