Five Boroughs Pizza Tavern - Pizza restaurant in Cumming - 1370 Buford Hwy #107, USA

Loved the vibe. The service was excellent. Food was fabulous. I highly recommend the Diavolo Peppers as an appetizer. They were so good!

Very rude! We use to get a specific pizza at this location and when I questioned on the phone the girl told me it didn’t exist . Called back a 2nd time and was passed to several people and the older dark haired lady that answers the phone, that ended the call, basically said it’s too late because it’s ready and hung up, very rudely. When I arrived the pizzas were not yet even in the oven. Regardless of how the food tastes, customer service is more important. Won’t be back!!! Take your money elsewhere to someone who appreciates your business- lady with dark hair , very poor countenance and obviously hates her job, is not interested in customer service!

Spotted this place while out for a drive and decided to give it a try. So glad we did! Excellent pizza! We got the Big Apple and all the ingredients blended so well together. Will definitely be back to try another!

I've been meaning to try this place for a while. This location has been a few different restaurants so we are happy to see Five Burroughs going strong. We got the stuff peppers, calamari, and the long Island. I would highly recommend the peppers and the Long Island pizza. The long Island was probably one of the most flavorful pizzas I've had. So good. The peppers had goat cheese and was service with bread. The calamari could use a little more flavor and seasoning but the marinara was really good. My only knock would be on the pizza preparers not wearing masks. The servers were however. All in all, we will return to try some of the other things on the menu. We wanted to try the chefs special but they were out of that.

Saturday night stop in. Bartender took care of us in the booth. Great service. There was live music. We went on a limb and had the garlic knots that were great, a meatball sub that we would not recommend and a caprese salad with chicken that tasted as great as it was presented. Prices were fair.

Fun atmosphere and really good gluten free pizza. The service was also very good. We'll be back!

We enjoy eating at this local pizza shop! The Diavolo Peppers starter is a must!! It’s seriously so good! The wings and pizza are also really flavorful. We definitely recommend trying this place out for a good pizza night.

The appetizers and pizza pies were great. Service was lacking a little. Server was overwhelmed. Will definitely return.