Finnegan’s Pub - Bar in Highland Mills - 504 NY-32, USA

The kind of pub where you know who everyone is. Free pool, free darts.

Nice little spot that let me play good music and had great prices but that bartender Nicky was horrible to deal with! Did nothing but complain and make my night nothing like it could of been. Probably won't be back unless it's a Monday night or might try the other on a Thursday! 😉

I really love the owners, they are a lovely young married couple! I had a really nice conversation with them when I was there. So sweet and friendly :) The weekend female bartender (I do not know her name, but she described herself as a Britney Spears look alike)...was unfriendly and kind of rude to my family, friends and I. We also collectively tipped her very well and there was absolutely no appreciation or thank you for our business. Instead she rushed us out of the bar (granted it was late and I know the feeling of a packed bar when you're tired and trying to go home)--however, there is a way to ask people to leave and this chick just doesn't know how to do it. My friend ran into her a week or two later at another pub and when she greeted her she was totally dismissed and given an attitude (mind you, my friend tipped her $22 on I believe a one drink tab). Just overall she had really bad energy and spirit and she certainly doesn't fit the atmosphere of the bar. People have bad days, but all of this combined seems this is just who she is. We were all drinking and tipsy but we were really nice, polite and I think good company and customers. I likely won't be going back on the weekends if she is working. I'm sorry :( Other than that like I said, I really like the place and layout and I hope Finnegan's stays around and prospers :) :) :) ***(Hi Owners! I can't "reply" to your response so I am hoping you see this update. The date was Saturday night late 9/18) :)

Me and my friends love this place when Jen or Mariah are working! Nikki is the worst most miserable bartender i have ever encountered in my 53 years going out to bars!!! Nikki is an extremely Unhappy lazy miserable person! If you ever come here come on Jen or Mariah Are working they are the best💜💜💜💜💜

Absolutely the best bar. Owners are great!! Definitely a recommended place

Great place for a first time visit, They sell lotterys they have poker games (not during covid-19) Timmy (owner) was very helpful & caring making sure we have everything Overheard the conversation the guys we're having with timmy. They all seem to like him, Worth the trip

Small quaint establishment. The bartender was very friendly and welcoming and the atmosphere was pleasant. Prices a little high but just thankful these places are allowed to be open now.

Wonderful Pub. Met the owner and he was a sweetheart. Made everyone feel like regulars. The bartenders were efficient and friendly. Will definitely be going back.