Fat Shack - American restaurant in Greeley - 2622 11th Ave, USA

The best part of my experience was the burger. "The Classic" is a 2-patty all-American cheeseburger. (Combo meal, $14.) But even though I really like salt (it's fat free!), the patties were too salty for me. Speaking of salt, does Fat Shack know there are other seasonings for fries? My SUPER salty fries seemed to have no other seasoning. Fat Shack's management needs to take a field trip to Red Robin, to study how they season their fries. A pet peeve of mine is when you're the customer, you say "thank you", and the person *you're giving money to* says nothing. Doesn't matter if it's in the checkout line at the grocery store, or when someone brings your food to the table as happened here. In fairness, 10 minutes later he did ask how everything was from across the room, and I (untruthfully) gave a thumbs-up. Fat Shack and every other restaurant asking for tips before service need to just stop. It's a hostage situation: "We're about to cook your food and can do whatever we want to it; would you like to tip?"

First time being here, and I really liked it. It's all in the name. We dined in which I recommend. The gentleman at the counter was very nice and explained everything to us very well. I can't wait to try a different sandwich. I love the fried oreos too.

This is a yummy burger joint that's open till 3 a.m. I highly recommend it but the staff was unwelcoming and maybe bcs it was in the wee hours of the night the atmosphere was dead 🤷‍♀️ OMG there fried cheesecake bites are delicious!

My burger was good aside from the fact that I asked for something and it wasn’t on it but I got fried Oreos and they were completely undercooked and so were the fries. And when my husband asked for salt and pepper on his sandwich he got questioned as to why he wanted it on there. The sandwiches were good but the rude questions and undercooked food was uncalled for.

The stellar service is the main winner here. The food is mostly fried and greasy- best eaten when you just don't have the energy to make a meal after a hard day. The sandwich bread is great. Some recipes have changed recently, for the better! I am particularly fond of their jalapeño poppers and their fried pickles, but there's really no wrong answer here. In the past they've also sent out coupons for free deep-fried oreos.

Came in to get a few appetizers and was really impressed with the quality of service. Mark did a great job in giving us great suggestions and providing quality service as well. I’ve only been here once before but I definitely will plan on coming back to this location. We ordered the mozzarella sticks, Mac n cheese bites and jalapeños poppers. High quality and tasted fresh as well.

They put way to much marinara on the sandwiches making them impossible to hold. Had four different types of food on my sandwich but I could only taste marinara. Employe at counter told me to order on a tablet and walked off. However he didn't log in to the device so we could order on it. Had to wait 5 minutes before he came back and we could actually order.

Second time here. Ordered online and got here a little early. To our surprise the orders had just come through so they were hot and freshly wrapped. I even added a thing of oreos separate to my online order with no problem and staff gladly to do that for me. This place is great, the staff is great, food is great, place is clean, like actually clean. Will be returning again and again.