Eric's Hand Tossed Pizza & Subs - Pizza restaurant in Oconomowoc - 1280 Brown St, USA

The staff there are super amazing! Their customer service is top class! They were super great to us. I have celiacs and we heard really great things about their pizza. We were on vacation and had no idea where we could eat and our hotel suggested this place. We got 2 medium 2 topping gluten free pizzas. It was $45 for the two pizzas. They tasted great! We got a ham and pineapple and the other pepperoni and sausage. It is a thin crust for gluten free. It tastes amazing and super fresh! Highly recommend you try this place if you have a chance.

Eric was manning the station , the calls were coming in, they've got a super efficient business the 15 minutes I was there for lunch. They've got a few tables outside with umbrellas, And inside as well. Couldn't get an updated picture of the menu... but the Italian bomber Sub was great!. They have a lot of different options, including gluten free pizza and sub bread as well. And veggie options. I usually don't get appetizers , but their boneless wings were excellent as well! Lots of options.

We were disappointed, I had saw other amazing reviews so we thought we would try it. The breadsticks were burnt black on the bottom and on the edges and we ended up throwing them out. The boneless wings were good but the wrong favor we ordered honey BBQ and these were not. The cheesy garlic bread was wonderful and everyone wanted more. The pizza was alright we got a large sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, and bacon. The hand tossed crust was burnt around the outside but It seemed a bit undercooked in the middle the favor was ok, but probably not a place I would return to. The couple of tables inside were dirty from previous diners and there were napkins on the floor.

I can't believe I have not written a review until now! Eric has high standards of quality for his ingredients. Everyone that comes to my house that want to order delivery always asks for his food. We always have a hard time deciding what to get because every thing we've had was wonderful! Pizzas and Subs are AMAZING!!!

Awesome service! Quality product...our crowd loved everything pizza!

Sub was custom and made to my liking. Came out fresh and hot. Better than the chain resturants.

Pizza was made to order, I like the front counter fireplace touch. only negative thing I would have to say is I spoke to 2 people standing there talking about a pick up but they both looked at the 3rd person who was eating and she came out and took care of me.

I went out of my way to try this place because a review said the gluten-free crust was amazing, but it is basically cardboard. One of the worst gf crusts I’ve tasted. (I’m sure the regular is great, but wanted to warn other Celiacs out there to not waste their time.)