Elmwood Inn - Restaurant in Rochester - 1256 Mt Hope Ave, USA

We went here for a company dinner with Hyundai and almost everyone was disappointed with their meals. The appetizers were good but after that the entrees went downhill. We came on a Friday night with a pretty big party for a restaurant that didn’t have many other customers besides the ones sitting at the bar. One waitress attended us and she did a pretty good job keeping up on all the drink orders, refills, and food orders. She did an amazing job, I cannot blame her for how the food came out. I ordered the World Series burger “medium well” and it came out the same color as a hockey puck all char in every bite. The guy next to me ordered the same “medium rare” and his was cooked to hockey puck as well. Others who ordered the fish and chips complained of lack of seasoning on the fish batter. But the buffalo wings were good, pretzel sticks, and quesadillas were all very good. Maybe the food is better when the kitchen isn’t cooking for a big party. 🤷🏽‍♂️ In response to message from the owner: on the contrary everyone complained about their meals that night and at work the next day. So much so we did another company dinner at a barbecue place, where normally we only do 1 during our trip. Also the VP was the one who paid he always leaves a huge tip because we are such a big party and it is a corporate card. The waitress as I mentioned above was not the problem as she didn't cook the food, so why should her tip suffer. Have a happy New Year.

The Fish and Fries were so so good!!! But lunch time was very busy and we had to wait for about 20-25 mins to get our food. Looked like they were a bit understaffed. Other than that, the service was great! Our server was very friendly. Highly recommend!

This was my second time to the Elmwood Inn and I was not disappointed. My buddy and I came out for their Friday Fish Fry and it was great! One of the very best we've had in a long time. We were seated quickly (no reservations), even though it was fairly busy (the parking lot was almost completely filled). Our server, Christine was attentive and friendly. I had the Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald Porter with the beer batter Fish Fry and my buddy had the Ellicottville Blood Orange Ale with the Panko Breaded Fish Fry. We both had the onion rings and cole slaw for our sides with tartar sauce in a separate cup. The fish was well cooked, fresh made and delicious. The onion rings were also great! If you're looking for a great Fish Fry on a Friday night, you won't go wrong at the Elmwood Inn, I'd recommend you give it a try.

Lisa was phenomenal! My friend had a burger with onion rings and I had the beer battered fish sandwich with coleslaw. Everything was wonderful and I would definitely return.

Although it seemed like there was only one waitress for our half of the restaurant, there was no doubt she was hustling to do her best and apologizing she couldn't be faster. She was cheerful and friendly and in no way grumpy so we felt a lot os sympathy for her. Right after leaving the restaurant, we went to a store to make a return and they had a sign on the door apologizing for being closed because they couldn't get the staff. The world has changed since Covid! By the way, the food was excellent and we were seated next to a burning fireplace. Wonderful ambiance!

I come here for the beer battered fish fry! So good!!! There's lots of room and seating here. Never had to wait long to be seated. I've visited here often with coworkers for lunch and we've always had a wonderful experience!

For the most part the food is usually good. French fries are outstanding! Today my grilled sandwich was awfully greasy but inside ingredients were delicious. Nachos ordered had cold chicken and stale tasting chips. Had it redone with fries and was good. Chicken still cold. Chicken should be replaced with chili!

Food is overall very good, significantly better than most other food in the area and priced mostly reasonably. Beer selection could be a bit better but is pretty standard for the area. Service is where this place shines, staff is extremely friendly and attentive (at least at the bar). Has a pretty large group of regulars and it's pretty obvious why, this place has nailed it's pub culture. Overall if you like local bars/restaurants I would definitely give it a shot.