Elm's Pizza Parlor - Pizza restaurant in Granville - 113 E Elm St, USA

First time ordering here. Have lived in the Newark area for over 6 years now. Decided to give it a try this evening. We were quoted 40 minutes wait time but that seemed fair for a Friday evening. After driving 15 minutes to pick up then 15 more home to eat we opened the box to big disappointment. The whole pizza BURNT ! with several pieces black and inedible. I called to report right away offering pictures but she said I didn’t need to show pictures. I wasn’t offered a replacement by delivery as I was told we were out of the “delivery area” and driving 30 minutes on my end wasn’t an option either. I was t even offered a refund to my form of payment (card) which was surprising. The only thing offered was a gift certificate by mail.

This place was recommended by a coworker of my husband and we decided to give it try. Well we get the pizza home and it appeared to have no sauce on it! We got garlic bread as well, it was 4 pieces of sandwich bread. It was burnt too, we paid $5 for 4 pieces of toast ridiculous! Called the next day to ask some questions and spoke with the owner who told me that they buy texas toast and make the garlic bread themselves and told me they handsauce all the pizza so they couldn't give an amount that is put on each pizza. The pizza was super dry I might add. And my husband had to wait about 10-15 minutes inside for anyone to realize he was there to pick up our order. We definitely won't be ordering from elms again!

Great local spot. Friendly staff. Loved the pizza. Old car shop has retained its character and is still making great food 38 years later. I'm told that 92 year old grandpa still comes in every day to grate the cheese. We'll be back!

Friendly people but there’s some disconnect- we ordered pep/mushroom/banana pepper and it came with pineapple instead of banana pepper. I took this pizza back and they apologized, confirmed I’d get pep/mushroom/hot pepper. Picked up replacement pizza, it’s got bell pepper instead of banana. I’m too tired to do anything else so I guess I’ll eat it. Stromboli was really good.

Excellent Ma & Pa Pizza Place. Staff was amazing and didn't complain one bit about a group of school kids coming in during lunch hours (10 kids plus 2 adults). Food was excellent and I will definitely be back! Pricing is good too! I will eat here over the chain companies anyday!

So so good, I used to go here when we visited my grandmother. Oh my goodness, it is still so delicious. Now, my husband is a fan. I wish we lived a little closer but, we will be back ☺️ it brought back some good memories!

Elms is the best! We had 2 side salads, ranch and Italian, fresh, bright, simple, and delicious! Stromboli w/pep, sausage mushrooms and extra homemade sauce, all is to die for! A must have every two weeks!

Elms pizza is outstanding. The crust is super crispy. We had never tried the French bread pizza before, and holy moly. Outstanding service and a local feel.